I did mean to ask - were you ultimately satisfied by mchack's answers? And how are you reading him right now?

*Illegal move!*

I'm rather surprised you have to ask.



Go on.

Uhhh...I just re-read to see what I'm missing as I'm...surprised you're surprised. You mention your suspicion in #68, and then don't really appear to address him again.

In #122 you ask wyrm why he targets mchack.
in #128 you respond to mchack about a voting technicality

I don't see anything else.

Are you assuming I should know just because you haven't shot (at) him in the 1 shot you've taken since then?

*click*

*yawn* Did you know that the highly sought after "Lucky Bastard Award" is still tied between bookwyrm and flub? both surviving 4 shots... wonder who gets it in the end.

Look, what do you expect?

There have been two scum deaths, unfortunately neither of them said or did a single thing in game or were targeted by any other players and the shots that killed them were taken by the mod.
Therefore we can read absolutely nothing into them. Everyone else has killed town, and considering about half of us (rough guess as I can't be bothered to check) half killed someone we can't all be scum.

So we keep shooting people on whatever suspicion we can muster until we've hit scum.

I kind of like bler's reasoning, I could see Bookwyrm being the last scum.

Equally I could see flub playing us (if he killed himself then it's game over, if not he looks reasonably townie for taking the risk).

Or you could be scum. Your push on Lift (and someone else.. mchack?) at the start of the game seemed contrived.

I could be scum, let's face it it's basically a 90% chance these days whatever ZFR will say about statistics.


So we just keep shooting.. nothing else to it, until someone does something to arouse actual suspicion.

If we wanted to do this properly then nobody should be allowed to shoot until we all pick a target, then we take it in turns to shoot until they are dead. Anyone deviating from that plan is shot too as scum.
But with one scum left that doesn't really work either as they no longer have anyone else to worry about shooting or protecting.


How was that?

I actually gave him more credit for his joke @ HSL. Sharp, no defensiveness shows he's still trying when scum!flub really wouldn't have much motive to.

No, you should know because I didn't address him again when he's made a number of actual posts.



Not sure if you're annoyed that I tried to get you to talk.


I"m off to bed, so I'll take my turn as to not stall the game while I'm asleep.

Shoot Bookwyrm627

*click*

No, you should know I'm not annoyed because I didn't shoot you again.


;)




Yet.

If enough tequila is consumed I guess we could try it......once.