Well played on your reads but I didn't find your or Vitek's arguments convincing and did think you came across scummy.

See you and Trent really did really get Flub & Lift. And I nearly got Lift too but was convinced you were the better target

Anyway this was my post before the blackout, just for fun:

Hehe you've kinda confirmed your Scum in your wind up post V

You can't know I'm town unless you are in fact Scum. I have a feeling it might just be game over if my Trent theory holds up.

You tunneled on Vitek and didn’t want to listen to anyone that didn’t agree with your opinion.

*scratches head*
You are aware I was town, right?

supplementscene, you did the same thing last game when you were convinced me and RWarehall were scumbuddies and just wouldn't even consider you could be wrong. You have to question your own actions when you play town.

Indeed, this was my post prior to you being revealed but I was pointing to the fact you were assuming I was town without knowing. Was sure you were scum. I was completely wrong but did you seem too scummy?

I think you did pretty well for a first game, particularly towards the end.
The accusation of Vitek was actually what made me sure you were town, because I knew scum wouldn't go to that effort (particularly when you had already achieved lynch on a townie), but I also knew it was wrong as Vitek was the only solid town read I had in the game.

As others have said, you just need to question your reads and actions. Getting too bogged down with what you believe is correct, particularly in the face of others telling you you're wrong, is never good for town. You have to always be open to changing your mind.

For the record, I hate myself.

flub, I just finished reading the killer qt.

dude, that was the best fake claim ever.

Well, this was my only third game, so I can't compare it with many other fake claims but I don't think I'd ever be able to come up with something like this. Great job.

Lift, nice one too.

Yeah, for two people with zero knowledge of Pokemon you came up with some pretty convincing fake claims :)

I think my Governor claim from the Space Station Epsilon game was pretty good... shame the game kind of fell apart for a variety of reasons, that may well have been my only scum win otherwise.
Probably the only time a fake claim successfully prevented my lynch too.

Also, it's too funny how yog's PR got both role-blocked and commuter-blocked.

/m70 "I don't think he's bluffing. That would be a big coincidence."

:D

Not especially, town had quite a few powers too, but since doc is a really common one it's a pretty ballsy falseclaim.

Don't feel bad. I got called out by the mod for being terrible in a game I wasn't even playing in.

Yep. You had me mostly figured out. I'll have to be careful to be less aggressive the next time I'm scum. Or more aggressive when I'm town. :-)


@Vitek: thank you for refusing to claim! I think that really saved our butts. ;-)


It was an exciting game to the end. I really doubted we would make it when trent and Vitek figured us out. And trent was untouchable too. But in the end we managed to throw enough dirt on Vitek after all ... barely.

I did not even refuse claim but w/e.


Yog is around and I learnt already people don't want to hear anything else so I will say, you all played perfectly (including me) and it was a pleasure.
Even deadbolt. It was great to chat with you, mate.

Once again it showed how on point it is to be concerned with profile pictures and that pursuing people for banalities is much more useful than actually trying to figure out who plays scummy. So the usual.


Nah, I am just bitching, overall it was fun. First half was kind of marred by many people posting very little or not posting at all but what can you do.

Which ones?
I lost track in Joe's descriptions so I could use some overview.

There was cop, commuter, roleblocker, loud visitor (not really useful role). What else?