adaliabooks: I hate to rain on your parade, but mchack actually mentioned deadbolt a number of times (mainly speaking about lynching him or him subbing out because of lurkiness) even if he never directly addressed him, which to be fair considering the number and content of my predecessors posts isn't really surprising..

adaliabooks: As for me, he directly addressed me in a quite substantial post D2 when we were both more available as neither of us were around for the end of D1 (if I remember correctly anyway).

Vitek: Where? I see one post after deadbot was already being subbed out.

I realise I would have to do it other way around as well to make it more accurate but I don't have time for that now as it is past midnight already and I did only what I had strength for.

Lifthrasil: Well, at least I broke your tunnel vision. That's something, I guess, if you are town. :-)
Its funny. I just realized something: your weak attack on Vitek actually helped convince me that Vitek isn't scummy. That's not a good basis to town- (or neutral-) read someone. I should do a re-read of both you and Vitek. But I don't have any time. Sorry. Im just quickly here between two meetings. I'll look in in the late evening.

Meanwhile lynch me if you must. We can afford an error, actually, thanks to having already eliminated one scum. Still, I would prefer to lynch scum over sacrificing myself.

CU later

Vitek: Here.
I wonder how well you read the game as it was one of the main topics for D2.

Lifthrasil: Yes, one role-blocker on each side is unusual, but not 'a little off' in the sense that it can't be true. Yogs having been a RB is confirmed by the mod. And if you believe trent being the cop, you should also believe that he has been blocked. Yogs, being confirmed town now, surely didn't block trent. That would only be a reasonable assumption if yogs had been a jailer who tried keeping trent safe. But according to his flip, he just puts his target to sleep and doesn't protect it. So there must be annother role-blocker. Who blocked the quasi-confirmed cop and therefore is scum.

2. a Traitor usually doesn't know who the scum members are. So no. In any case it's weird that you try to throw shade at trent ... and further below mention him as your towniest read.

About your post #538: yes, going back over mchack's posts I can see where the impression comes from. He really never pushed me. But the same can be said about Sage, where he alternated between moderately supporting her and suspecting her just for show without actually pushing (apart from asking for her to be replaced). So, by your own reasoning Sage looks like mchack's buddy. Which would make you scum ... which, thinking about it, does fit quite well! Side note: post 215, which you quote, was aimed at ZFR, I think. Not primarily at me.

Lifthrasil: Hunter - sure, that will appear OMGUS. But the way how he first tried to throw doubt at trent looked scummy. Then, when that didn't work, he rowed back and joined the consensus that trent is town. To me that looks like scum testing whether trent's 'confirmed town' status can't be shaken up a bit. Understandable, since a confirmed cop is about the most dangerous thing for scum that there is.

supplementscene: I think SPF has had a strange approach to the game.

Lifthrasil: First lurking, then making a bogus case against Vitek, then latching on to trent's suspicion. All things that would fit for scum.

adaliabooks: So you just did what would make me look the worst?
Got you.

Hunter65536: Sometimes the person is just out having a good time, doesn't always have to be a role blocker. I guess Occam's razor kind of thing.
...
Also sage wasn't around as much as you were so the number of possible interactions is much lower to begin with.

Vitek: Also misdirection from what, mr. OMGUS? SPF's lynch which I support as well? Or from sitting around and doing nothing?

adaliabooks: The one warning ping I'm getting is Hunter voting for Lift as he is a strong candidate for the remaining scum and bussing his buddy at this juncture would seem unlikely.

adaliabooks: Plus the possibility of SPF being a roleblocker based on his soft claiming Pikachu makes it quite likely he could be scum...

trentonlf: *quote just to ping you*

Vitek: Why Hunter?
For his or Sage's play?

Vitek: Why would Pikachu equal RB?



Vitek: Did you get any flavour for your RB?

adaliabooks: ................

Electric Pokémon practically all have paralyzing attacks of some kind. Paralyze stops you acting, like sleep (which would be the result of yogs' Sing attack) so would make a good roleblocker flavour.
And SPF literally used one of those attacks as his vote against lift (Thunderwave) which doesn't necessarily mean much but I can't shake the feeling he's our remaining roleblocker.

JoeSapphire: snip