It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #54 - Pokemon Death Tournament(835 posts)(835 posts)
(835 posts)
Pages:
1
2
3
4
5
6
10
20
30
40
50
56
This is my favourite topic
Posted August 26, 2018
avatar
mchack: so if I say tickle sage somewhere in a sentence, I can later say I actually had voted her and you just somehow overlooked it?
I agree. I think we should stick to bolding our votes, so that there is no wiggle room later!
Posted August 26, 2018
avatar
JoeSapphire: I'll try to count unbolded attacks, but emboldening them is safer
avatar
mchack: I'm pretty sure, this'll lead to problems.
You have now allowed voting new people without unvoting before and without even saying the word vote and without having to bold the vote

so if I say tickle sage somewhere in a sentence, I can later say I actually had voted her and you just somehow overlooked it?
I'm going to second this. Not requiring unvotes is one thing, but skipping the bolding AND the word vote seems like it is asking for trouble.

However, you're the mod, so your call.
Posted August 26, 2018
avatar
Lifthrasil: I agree. I think we should stick to bolding our votes, so that there is no wiggle room later!
I agree. Since the word vote can be replaced by anything that could be construed as an attack it makes it too hazy if you also don't require bolding.
Posted August 26, 2018
avatar
ZFR: Hehe. I like how your explanation is full of "we"s
avatar
Lifthrasil: While for you Town are 'they'. Sure, you handwaved that away after trent pointed it out. But I still wonder whether he was on to something and that was an early slip by you.
Heh.

Actually, when I first read it, all those "we"s in your post jst appeared a bit amusing, but otherwise NAI. Would a townie do it after what trent wrote? Sure. Would a scum do it? Of course. When I made my post above, it was just a comment of something I found funny.

Later however, what struck me is why you made this post in the first place. Your first 2 points are just reiterations of what has already been said by three people. Why repeat it? Maybe it was beacuse you wanted to make the third point about liars. It's important to give advice to newbies after all. I know supplementscene already knows about lying being because that was already beaten to death in the Secret Hitler game that we played, but maybe it's not something that you'd know...

Except that you were in that game too. In fact you were one of the first people to touch upon that topic. Here is me for example stressing the point that you originally made:
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/secret_hitler_1_legend_of_the_cows/post154

So why did you want to repeat to scene something that he already should be know.

The more I look at it, the more I see that the only reason to your post was to throw in all those TOWN=WE. It seems not borderline LAMIST but almost excessively so.

If I were still on bler's avatar, I'd say I'd eat my hat that you're not town.

Unvote
Kick Lifthrasil
Posted August 26, 2018
avatar
ZFR: ...
Now you're really stretching. I replied because scene asked. If he gets everyones opinions he can form his own conclusions. It's the polite thing to do to reply when someone asks a question.

I find it more interesting that you try to turn your own slip around. Trent caught you at labeling town as 'they'. Doesn't need to be a slip but can be one. And the way how try to turn it around pretending that now, for some reason, using 'we' with respect to town is a sign of scumminess just looks a bit desperate.

So, let's throw in a bit of OMGUS with your LAMIST and
unvote
shame ZFR
Posted August 26, 2018
avatar
Lifthrasil: And the way how try to turn it around pretending that now, for some reason, using 'we' with respect to town is a sign of scumminess.
Heh. I never said "using 'we' with respect to town is a sign of scumminess". I said that's NAI. Scumminess is how you crammed so much of it for no reason. You didn't add anything new for scene. Just repeated what multiple people told him. What new conclusion can he form with your "additional" info.

With that in mind, I hope the irony in your statement that I quoted doesn't escape you.
Posted August 26, 2018
avatar
Lifthrasil: ...........

So, let's throw in a bit of OMGUS with your LAMIST and
unvote
shame ZFR
This looks like a recipe for something.

I'm now looking at you with the squinty eyes.
Posted August 26, 2018
avatar
Lifthrasil: ..............

Grapple Sage
avatar
flubbucket: Awesome.

Unlock: d3adb01t
;__;
Posted August 27, 2018
avatar
Bookwyrm627: Bookwyrm
--------------
avatar
mchack: ... pound each other? (that doesn't sound right)
Giggles..It sounds right if you have a mind of a teenager =)

Ima pound away.

avatar
supplementscene: Greetings gentlemen & gentleladies. My first game of Mafia, although I've played Secret Hitler.

So let's talk Town Tactics. The Pros & Cons of 'vote no elimination' in round 1? Does that play into Mafia hands?

Is anyone open to talking about their role? Or do you prefer to keep the cards close to your chest?

Not attacking anyone just yet, going to sit back and feel this one out for now.
/Watching supple with a close eye

Welcome to the game. However, talkuing roles is way way to early. Why give out information that scum can use to their advantage to try to blend in.


avatar
Lifthrasil: Grapple Sage
/Remove grapple.

Thanks Lift. I would have figured the action would have been something else. lol

avatar
JoeSapphire: ugh I should have seen that coming...
avatar
flubbucket: I'm really quite uncomplicated.

For the record, I really want to "Grapple Sage" but I think it might come off as just a bit creeeepy.
haha I was thinking it was more on the less creepy side

I see Hyper and Lift are already in a battle. This is going to be a fun game.


I also agree we should have to bold our votes so nothing can be misconstrued.
Jump on Flub's back attack
Posted August 27, 2018
avatar
Sage103082: Giggles..It sounds right if you have a mind of a teenager =)

Ima pound away.

/Watching supple with a close eye

Welcome to the game. However, talkuing roles is way way to early. Why give out information that scum can use to their advantage to try to blend in.


/Remove grapple.

Thanks Lift. I would have figured the action would have been something else. lol

haha I was thinking it was more on the less creepy side

I see Hyper and Lift are already in a battle. This is going to be a fun game.


I also agree we should have to bold our votes so nothing can be misconstrued.
Jump on Flub's back attack
The funny part is that Hyper is not playing this game...
Posted August 27, 2018
avatar
Sage103082: .............
Jump on Flub's back attack
My first thought upon seeing this.
Posted August 27, 2018
avatar
Sage103082: .............
Jump on Flub's back attack
avatar
flubbucket: My first thought upon seeing this.
Kinda but meow....
Posted August 27, 2018
Hyper --- wanna tell us why you are posting in a game you are not involved in ?
Posted August 27, 2018
avatar
Sage103082: Hyper --- wanna tell us why you are posting in a game you are not involved in ?
Hyper is neither playing, nor posting in this game. It's for the greater good.
Posted August 27, 2018
define greater good
Pages:
1
2
3
4
5
6
10
20
30
40
50
56
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #54 - Pokemon Death Tournament(835 posts)(835 posts)
(835 posts)