nmorello11: Syberia 1+2 collection. Not a bad game (the first one), it just took me so long to get to it in my backlog, and when I did, I only played like 7 hours before getting bored. I still have yet to play the second game, but I bought it on a 75% off sale for like $3, so it wasn't that much of a loss.
Guild Wars 2. Again, I'm not going to call this a bad game...but I only got like 20 hours out of my $30 purchase, and considering that I have spent far less on games, and gotten far more time out them (heck, I think I got that same amount of time out of the World of Warcraft demo), this was a much bigger loss.
I bought Syberia for $20 way back when Syberia 2 was being released and bough Syberia 2 for $40 before having played the first one. I was fooled and hoping for another TLJ masterpiece, silly me.
I also bought GW2 collector's edition because I had spent so much time in GW 4v4 matches I thought it would just get better. DER.
Star Wars: The Old Republic. WORST. "GAME." PURCHASE. EVER.
The Broken Sword series. I bought them all on a bundle sale once, repeatedly have tried to get into them and the first game is just SO fecking boring.
ohyeah! SW:TOR was sooo horrible and I was so furious with how horrible it was (I played to lvl 46 of a jedi sentinel) I talked and talked to the parties involved (amazon, bethesda, and my CC company) until I got a refund of my collector's edition as well as a refund for 6months I had already paid for. YEAH! I was pretty sure it was the CC company that put the pressure on EA to give me a mostly full refund. Amazon was great the whole time.