I see it the other way. On Steam you have to pay for something, on GOG you get it for free (or about 85% of it). That makes Steam customers second class citizens.

It might not be perfect that you can't obtain the missing four tracks here. But there's no way that these games belong on the list. Would send a very wrong signal to developers in my eyes. The list should be for developers and publishers who neglect their product here, not for those who are nice by giving away stuff for free you normally have to pay for.

But Steam users pay for the high quality (wav, flac) full OST, while GOG users get for free the low quality (mp3 only) incomplete OST. If both OSTs were equal, Steam users would be second class citizens, but that's not the case.

And yet GOG users get something for free that users of other services don't get. Which certainly doesn't make them second class citizens. I don't argue that it's a perfect solution, but I argue that cases like these don't belong on the list.

Just my 2 cents: I doubt that you will find a clear solution here. Steam is missing the low quality free incomplete soundtrack and GOG is missing the high quality complete soundtrack to pay for. So whatever is worth more wins ... and imo that's pretty subjective.

Only additions this time....

Added
Close to the Sun - missing Hungarian, missing standalone OST and artbook DLCs (basically the Deluxe upgrade if you will), it's either standard or Deluxe.*
Northgard - Linux version is missing multiplayer (no Galaxy on Linux)
Neversong - missing "Coma HD" DLC

*Also Deluxe is a bundle on Steam which makes it potentially cheaper - might be added to the entry after investigation

Another reason to add Mafia 2 and 3 is the price. On Steam, each Definitive Edition costs 30 bucks. Here, Mafia 2 costs 40, while Mafia 3 Complete costs 60.

The Mafia 3 size difference is due to remnants of a cancelled game being left in the definitive edition, mainly a complete (but untextured) and accessible game world of Berlin.

Thank you. Finally an explanation - so the temp files in my folder were obviously part of the same mistake. Hopefully they will remove those unnecessary files in a future update. Thank you!

Not to stir up a fuss, because the game is great and the dev seems to be a decent guy, but in good conscience I wouldn't recommend getting Supraland on GOG anymore, due to the comments in this thread.

It's not a good sign for new indie games on GOG in general, I think, if devs perceive all the effort involved to be not worth the outcome. (And I do believe that the dev has a point, even though it sucks and it's not fair to the Steam-averse users who bought it here.)

What I can’t u sera tans, and it’s never been explained, is what all this extra effort is? I mean you write a game, package it up (automatic build pipelines), and push it out to the store, it’s the same regardless of store. Or is it integrating galaxy functionality which is the extra? That I can understand. Anyways, was looking at buying this, so that can get scratched from the list, it’s just too much effort for me to keep up a GOg wish list for it.

I don't know either, but one difference seems to be that on Steam the devs can handle everything on their own, while on GOG they have to communicate with GOG's staff for everything and depend on the staff for e.g. when GOG will test the game/DLC/update, when they will create an installer for it, when they will put it up etc.

The whole store?

Pretty much so, since recently GOG treats their old customers like non existent and second class customers!

Those dev comments in the thread are so gross. The game didn't sell as well here as you thought, ok but what about people like me who DID buy it here and who don't want a Scheme key? Based on the comments in that thread I read so far, I think this game should be de-listed by GOG. Other unsupported games were delisted in the past, and it looks like that's where we are headed here. It would be great if refunds were issued too albeit that's not totally fair to GOG since they can't totally "know" if a dev is/isn't going to flake from the outset. And I am not some "hater", I've talked up this game in a few topics and said how it is really cool. I am generally wary of indie games but this one stands out! It's a shame that, yet again, the treatment of GOG buyers is not so awesome.