Matewis: Oh I still have to try that game at some point, though I'm staying away from now. As I've seen with Nethack, Dwarf Fortress and CDDA, once one of these games get its hooks in you you're screwed :)
From what I've read though I don't think CDDA is nearly as difficult as ADOM. I don't believe there are much or anything along the lines of 'cheap deaths' in CDDA like there is in Nethack and, I believe I've read, ADOM. Well except perhaps when a Moose decide it doesn't like you when you are out foraging in the woods :P
edit: actually that is one of the things that kind of put be off about ADOM when first I read up on it. I read that it was very easy to suffer a quick and unexpected death? In Nethack I don't mind so much because of the whole format of the game, but in ADOM with its big world and more 'traditional' rpg approach I'm not sure I would tolerate it that well.
Hmmm, come to think of it I might not have tolerated it that well in Nethack either. I kinda gave up after my last character: a very powerful ranger that stepped on a polymorph trap and met his end as a rodent being pummpeled to death inside an air elemental :P
I don't think ADOM is too unfair.. it's a roguelike so it's tough, but no more than usual for the genre.
There are areas that are very difficult and will likely earn you a swift death if you visit them too early, but with a bit of trial & error you soon learn where is safe and where isn't.
To be honest when I played it regularly (years ago) I was a save scummer and that's the only way I've ever progressed reasonably in it, but these days if I give it a try I do it properly (and die lots).
dtgreene: I happen to like this sort of mechanic, and I wish more games would adopt it.
By the way, have you played any of the SaGa games? Many of them use this sort of mechanic for stat/skill growth.
Also, Wizardry 8 combines this sort of mechanic (for skill growth) with traditional leveling (for stat/hp growth and other things, including spell learning).
No, I haven't played any of them. I'll probably give them a try at some point, they do sound interesting.
I've not played any Wizardry games either, they've never really been of interest to me.