Posted September 30, 2015
Matewis: To be honest, I've never tried it :P It just so happened that I started with the 2nd one, and because I found it so perfect I half expect it would be difficult for me to now try out the original. Mechanics wise though, it seems that the two games are pretty close together.
I suspect Disciples vs Disciples 2 is kind of like HoMM2 vs HoMM3. Some people will claim 2 is better than 3, and some(most?) will claim 3 is better than 2. It's easier to play 3 after 2 than it is to play 2 after 3, so if you're only going to play one then it makes more sense to play 3. But if you are in any case going to play both then it makes sense to start with 2, pending a risk assessment. The risk being that the gameplay features a novel mechanic/feel and it will only be novel once, so you have to personally decide if you want to have a novel experience with 2 or 3. It's a risk because the novelty adds to the experience, and it will be lost/reduced by the time you play 3 if you first play 2.
I suppose there everyone has to make up his/her own mind, but for me it makes Disciples 2 the more attractive place to start.
However this does not factor in the possibility that you already own one of the games :P I suppose it would be a great pity, or even injustice, to own 1 and to shoot straight to 2 without giving 1 a proper go :)
Now then, I'll give it a try sometime in the days/weeks, as my time allows. Like the OP said - I really like the genre but I suck so much at playing these games that I only bought them, but never seriously played them.I suspect Disciples vs Disciples 2 is kind of like HoMM2 vs HoMM3. Some people will claim 2 is better than 3, and some(most?) will claim 3 is better than 2. It's easier to play 3 after 2 than it is to play 2 after 3, so if you're only going to play one then it makes more sense to play 3. But if you are in any case going to play both then it makes sense to start with 2, pending a risk assessment. The risk being that the gameplay features a novel mechanic/feel and it will only be novel once, so you have to personally decide if you want to have a novel experience with 2 or 3. It's a risk because the novelty adds to the experience, and it will be lost/reduced by the time you play 3 if you first play 2.
I suppose there everyone has to make up his/her own mind, but for me it makes Disciples 2 the more attractive place to start.
However this does not factor in the possibility that you already own one of the games :P I suppose it would be a great pity, or even injustice, to own 1 and to shoot straight to 2 without giving 1 a proper go :)