Solei: And another good place to look is metacritic:
http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/elite-dangerous/user-reviews?sort-by=date&num_items=100 This is not a score i associate with a good game ;)
While the online DRM is one of the biggest problems with Elite Dangerous, it's far from the only one. The game is essentially nothing more than a prettier version of the first Elite, and basically gets rid of all the advances that Frontier and First Encounters brought with it. And while the first Elite was a marvel for its time, the fact remains that there was never very much to do in the game. Once you had your trade routes down pat and sussed out the rather predictable enemy AI, that was it.
It's all well and good to claim that "it's all about setting your own goals"; but ultimately the game needs to provide freedom and scope to do that. All you can do is trade, kill pirates...and that's about it. Everything that Elite: Dangerous does (except for the ship handling) is done better by other games. X3 was the better game overall. EVE Online does the MMO aspect better. Frontier/First Encounters had more variety (and Star Citizen is looking to offer the same). Heck, even X-Rebirth had more ambition than E:D. Even Rodina, a one-man effort (as yet unfinished), shows more ambition, by letting you walk around on planets and walk around your ship.