It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionForum Mafia Game #40 - Wilderberry Hollow(1653 posts)(1653 posts)
(1653 posts)
Pages:
1
25
50
53
54
55
56
57
100
111
This is my favourite topic
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
a4plz: ...
avatar
drealmer7: Gee, it would have been nice if you would have realized that before blindly blazing in and killing someone. Liiiike maybbe that 1st day of the 1st Day when you didn't even bother to read the rules and then showed you didn't care to understand what was going on/how the game is played. When did it hit you that it wasn't like a quick werewolf game, before or after hammering HijacK? 2 weeks prior?

smh...apology NOT accepted

avatar
trentonlf: ...
I'm sorry to see you leave...
avatar
drealmer7: I bet you are!

translation: "thanks for making scum's job easy, you totally won it for us, we couldn't have done it (so easily) without you! I hope you enjoyed pooping on other people's fun, I know I enjoyed watching it because I'm a scummy bastard!!" --- I'm always wrong though!
Drealmer, show some graciousness please. There is a phrase, "Those who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones", that I think applies to you in this scenario. You've rage quit, deliberately breaking the rules to incur a mod kill, at least once, and I believe more than once, because things weren't going to your liking.
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
cristigale: I have been thinking this over. Town needs this information heading forward. I believe the positives of sharing this outweigh potential negatives.

I was the Undertaker (Coroner). I choose to investigate HijacK last night. To my surprise, I actually received the results from that investigation. HijacK was in fact the Herbalist. We're now sitting behind the eight ball. Anyone who is town, can we please put petty bickering aside? If you think someone is scum, state your reason and vote for them. We need to work together and have a bit of luck at this point to have a chance to win.

I'm not sure I would have revealed w/o the information on HijacK.

It's been a long day and I'm headed to bed. I have plenty of time this weekend to answer questions and share additional thoughts.
Obviously we are in dire straits now with two of three power roles dead.

avatar
adaliabooks: .....................

And drealmer, take a chill pill. It's only a game, no need for all the caps and swearing. What you said to a4plz was completely out of order, quite frankly if there is any one spoiling the enjoyment of this game it's you.
Amen!!!
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
cristigale: I have been thinking this over. Town needs this information heading forward. I believe the positives of sharing this outweigh potential negatives.

I was the Undertaker (Coroner). I choose to investigate HijacK last night. To my surprise, I actually received the results from that investigation. HijacK was in fact the Herbalist. We're now sitting behind the eight ball. Anyone who is town, can we please put petty bickering aside? If you think someone is scum, state your reason and vote for them. We need to work together and have a bit of luck at this point to have a chance to win.

I'm not sure I would have revealed w/o the information on HijacK.

It's been a long day and I'm headed to bed. I have plenty of time this weekend to answer questions and share additional thoughts.
avatar
adaliabooks: Well well well. That does put an interesting spin on things.
I tend to believe you as I've mostly had you leaning town, and I still don't quite see scum killing their own N2, but there is certainly the possibility of you being scum and this being a ploy (though the fact you voted HijacK too really makes that unlikely)

Either way, it does look like things may have played out slightly differently than expected.

Well, looks like trent was the scum after all.

Unvote drealmer7
Vote trentonlf

And drealmer, take a chill pill. It's only a game, no need for all the caps and swearing. What you said to a4plz was completely out of order, quite frankly if there is any one spoiling the enjoyment of this game it's you.
I'm not scum, and I'm not sure of your reasoning as to why I must be. If Hijack was the herbalist I was wrong about him, but that does not make me scum. He was not invested in this game and was behaving in a way that lead me to believe he was scum. You were pushing for him harder than I was based on those reasons as well. So explain to me exactly why I'm scum after all?
Posted May 14, 2016
Also....Welcome to:

adaliabooks

yogsloth

RWarehall



(sorry so slow, family in town)
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
babark: Cristi, could you perhaps hint at the results of your investigations the first night, in a way that won't put anyone in jeopardy?
What results? The coroner can only investigate dead people (spectres included), and going into N1 there wasn't any dead. Or do you assume that cristi had advanced knowledge of who would die on N1?
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
JMich: What results? The coroner can only investigate dead people (spectres included), and going into N1 there wasn't any dead. Or do you assume that cristi had advanced knowledge of who would die on N1?
Ohyeah, of course. We were only notified of Bookwyrm's death the next day...
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
trentonlf: I'm not scum, and I'm not sure of your reasoning as to why I must be. If Hijack was the herbalist I was wrong about him, but that does not make me scum. He was not invested in this game and was behaving in a way that lead me to believe he was scum. You were pushing for him harder than I was based on those reasons as well. So explain to me exactly why I'm scum after all?
Sorry trent, you were just bait :)

Unvote trentonlf
Vote babark

I wanted to see if anyone would follow me, and babark did. Not damning evidence, but I'm happy to park my vote there for now.

First I'd like to say, on the off chance that cristi is lying I think now would be a good time for the real coroner to claim.
I find this a highly unlikely possibility, but I'm putting it out there just in case someone is holding back.
If cristi is actually lying then we are three power roles to one remaining scum (but the chances of that actually being the case are next to none)

I think we're in pretty dire straits now, to be honest I can't even see a way for us to win with (presumably, unless we assume Bookwyrm is scum after all) three (or more) scum left to kill and only one power role keeping us alive. We need to get lucky three times in a row, they just need to get lucky once.

I think I've spotted a slip. However I'm not sure if it's our one remaining power role, or a scum slip.
What does everyone think, is it worth pointing it out or is the risk that it's the power role too great?
Personally I think we're basically screwed so I'd go for it, but I don't want to lose this for everyone else... (any more then I may have already anyway)
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
adaliabooks: First I'd like to say, on the off chance that cristi is lying I think now would be a good time for the real coroner to claim.
I disagree in the strongest possible terms. If the coroner is still alive, then keep your mouth shut about it today.

avatar
adaliabooks: I think I've spotted a slip. However I'm not sure if it's our one remaining power role, or a scum slip.
What does everyone think, is it worth pointing it out or is the risk that it's the power role too great?
Personally I think we're basically screwed so I'd go for it, but I don't want to lose this for everyone else... (any more then I may have already anyway)
Point it out. May as well go for broke.
Posted May 14, 2016
Vote Adaliabooks

Seriously, I've been playing this game less than half a day. And you are pushing for a Coroner to claim if Christie is lying?

First off, I don't see why you are convinced mafia might kill one of their own for the NK. I don't see that as a reasonable possibility. As far as I'm concerned I have no doubts about our body impaired friends.

For the love of God, this game especially, no power role discussion (at least regards existing players)...
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
adaliabooks: First I'd like to say, on the off chance that cristi is lying I think now would be a good time for the real coroner to claim.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: I disagree in the strongest possible terms. If the coroner is still alive, then keep your mouth shut about it today.

Point it out. May as well go for broke.
Why? If the coroner is still alive that means cristi is lying (and scum), if cristi is scum it only makes sense for her to lie if HijacK was also scum (though I suppose knowing we were one power role down they might take the risk to out another and use HijacK's wagon to frame trent, me and anyone else on it...)

Ok, I see where you're coming from. Claiming is perhaps not the best move (though if HijacK wasn't the herbalist I still think it would be worth it as we would know there are two scum down, the coroner can still possibly be saved and we know a lot more about what's going on)

I'll wait to see what a few others say.

While you're here... there seems to be a bit more to the Spectres mechanics then already revealed, unless I'm just reading too much into your interchange with cristi... you are still town right?

@agent I know you said there were bastard elements to this game, were any of them that you have lied in the rules?
(I doubt you'll answer this, but I thought I'd check)
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
adaliabooks: @agent I know you said there were bastard elements to this game, were any of them that you have lied in the rules?
(I doubt you'll answer this, but I thought I'd check)
He said that?
Posted May 14, 2016
Unvote adialiabooks
Vote adaliabooks

Just to make it clear that I'm no longer leaning off your wagon.

We so need to know if hijack and or Christi were scum. The only person that helps is sreamler7 as right now he reads hella town.

You seem empowered by the news that two PR are likely gone. You seem cavalier about it all. And if I'm not mistaken you voted for both dreamer and hijack wagon ( and also feeling like you voted for Worym and cristigale ).
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
adaliabooks: @agent I know you said there were bastard elements to this game, were any of them that you have lied in the rules?
(I doubt you'll answer this, but I thought I'd check)
avatar
RWarehall: He said that?
Yeah, but I found the quote and he explicitly ruled out lying to us, so that's fine.

(from the sign up thread)

This is going to be a small semi-open game. It is also going to be bastard. Be warned.

@ all - According to Krypsyn, the game isn't really bastard. It just has rather a lot of experimental mechanics that probably aren't balanced very well at all. So I won't be lying to anyone, and I certainly expect the game to be fun. But don't expect balance or normality or anything boring like that.
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
adaliabooks: @agent I know you said there were bastard elements to this game, were any of them that you have lied in the rules?
(I doubt you'll answer this, but I thought I'd check)
I have not lied as far as I know. It's possible I've made mistakes, or left out bits that were important. But I have not intentionally lied.
Posted May 14, 2016
avatar
RWarehall: First off, I don't see why you are convinced mafia might kill one of their own for the NK. I don't see that as a reasonable possibility. As far as I'm concerned I have no doubts about our body impaired friends.
I'm not, I explicitly stated I found it very unlikely. But if she is lying, and particularly if HijacK was too, then town is in a pretty good position rather than a spectacularly awful one.

avatar
lotsofchickenwings: We so need to know if hijack and or Christi were scum. The only person that helps is sreamler7 as right now he reads hella town.

You seem empowered by the news that two PR are likely gone. You seem cavalier about it all. And if I'm not mistaken you voted for both dreamer and hijack wagon ( and also feeling like you voted for Worym and cristigale ).
Sooo... you agree that we need to know if they're lying, but are voting me for suggesting a real town coroner might claim (the only thing which could prove their alignment either way)?

:/
Something doesn't add up there.

I'm not empowered, I probably am cavalier. It's a game, you win some, you lose some. As it looks like we're pretty close to losing this one anyway there's not really much to lose.
I did vote both drealmer and HijacK, I have never voted Bookwyrm or cristi, though Dess might have day 1.

Anyway, if you lynch me today then town definitely loses.
But it's up to you guys.
Pages:
1
25
50
53
54
55
56
57
100
111
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionForum Mafia Game #40 - Wilderberry Hollow(1653 posts)(1653 posts)
(1653 posts)