It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionForum Mafia Game #40 - Wilderberry Hollow(1653 posts)(1653 posts)
(1653 posts)
Pages:
1
18
19
20
21
22
25
50
75
100
111
This is my favourite topic
Posted May 01, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: ...oops...
bump, in case you actually want to vote jmich
Posted May 01, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: ...oops...
avatar
drealmer7: bump, in case you actually want to vote jmich
Thanks. I was sitting and waiting for the timer this time.

Unvote.
Vote JMich.

Clearly man has some black magic that keeps making me screw up my voting.
Posted May 01, 2016
avatar
JMich: Easter celebrations done, back at home, time to read what has happened in the last 2 days. Let's see if anything noteworthy has happened, or if wyrm wishes for someone to stir the pot and takes pot shots at me for not doing so (yes, I did glimpse at the last few posts to see if someone was lynched).
Happy Easter. Sounds strange...Western Eastern was early this year, so Easter seems like the distant past.

With the deadline approaching, it would be nice to hear your read on the past few days. Is there anyone you find scummy?

Does a horrible human person possess any of the black magic that bookwyrm referred?
Posted May 01, 2016
avatar
drealmer7: I
Disparaging Friends and then voting No Lynch, you have to be scum

Unvote Hijack
Vote drealmer
Posted May 01, 2016
reposting in case it was glossed over:

with the deadline 'less than' 24 hours away, I'd like to hear who everyone is willing/comfortable enough to vote and lynch today - topped with raisins is always preferred, of course

we need to avoid EoD lynch-rush more often in all games, and most definitely in this game, it's not helpful to town at all to play that way
Posted May 01, 2016
avatar
drealmer7: Dessimu - wayyyy off his meta from normal and it feels very odd + seems a bit more focused on me makes me think he's got some fear of my mad skillzzzz

Dess, your attitude seems very very very different this game as opposed to other games, anything you can share about that?
Meta change - three things:
1. I am (d)evolving?
2. if you base your scum readings mostly on meta of players I can see yourself already making inaccurate observations
3. some recent real life events may have influenced my behavior. But I do not feel like sharing.

Your "mad skils":
1. you have some, but...
2. ...in this game I find yourself acting more like a pompous...man. It makes you not scummy, but rather disliked.
Posted May 01, 2016
avatar
drealmer7: I'd also like to talk more about no-lynch now that we're closer to the deadline.
No-lynch may make sense in this game, but I don't think it works for N1. While the OP hints that we may not get much information out of the flip, we need a lynch to confirm what information we will/won't get. We don't know if lynches and NK's will flip with the same information or not. With a coroner in the game, I'm not expecting much on flip but we need to confirm it.

*refresh

avatar
drealmer7: I
avatar
trentonlf: Disparaging Friends and then voting No Lynch, you have to be scum

Unvote Hijack
Vote drealmer
trent - this feels out of character
Posted May 01, 2016
Scum list please.

If the previous wish doesn't work, then I guess I'll settle for a
Vote count please.
Posted May 01, 2016
avatar
drealmer7: Dessimu - wayyyy off his meta from normal and it feels very odd + seems a bit more focused on me makes me think he's got some fear of my mad skillzzzz

Dess, your attitude seems very very very different this game as opposed to other games, anything you can share about that?
avatar
Dessimu: Meta change - three things:
1. I am (d)evolving?
2. if you base your scum readings mostly on meta of players I can see yourself already making inaccurate observations
3. some recent real life events may have influenced my behavior. But I do not feel like sharing.

Your "mad skils":
1. you have some, but...
2. ...in this game I find yourself acting more like a pompous...man. It makes you not scummy, but rather disliked.
#1 - is what I was figuring. I also have it in mind that you were scum in what, 2/4 of your last games, and so my reads on you as town are not yet much established at all

#2 - don't worry, it's not even close to "mostly", it's simply a part of the whole to consider

#3 - no worries, I understand, thanks for saying that much at least

re: mad skillz

#2 - damn, I'm sorry for that, I seriously thought I toned down the pompous this game. Are you sure it's not because it's directed at you this time a bit ? (whereas in past games we've been kind of of the same mind/on the same side of arguments/viewpoints) and so I'm just rubbing you a bit wrong?

avatar
cristigale: ...we need a lynch to confirm what information we will/won't get. We don't know if lynches and NK's will flip with the same information or not. With a coroner in the game, I'm not expecting much on flip but we need to confirm it.
I'm listening and following. Can you elaborate on why we "need" to confirm what the flips will be like? We'll find out sooner or later either way, I'm sure. Why the rush to confirm how they will be? Once we confirm how flips are for lynches, what good does that do us one way or the other and why is it more valuable to have that information D1 instead of D2? (I'm not arguing against that it will, I'm simply asking you to follow through on the logic/scenario so I can fully see what value you see in having the confirmation of flip-type sooner rather than later.)
Posted May 01, 2016
Quick cider fueled read done. Usual day 1 "arguments", with newbies lurking or making questionable statements, HijacK having exams and partying, and a couple of people bashing heads. More or less the same as any game that starts on D1.
Pings noticed:
1) a4plz suggestions do raise eyebrows. I do not wish any newbies to be lynched on D1, so while I will be keeping an eye on him/her, I won't be placing a vote on them. Nor will I vote for babark or lotsofchickenwings atm.
2) HSL does appear a bit over aggressive with his questioning. Probably the cider making me paranoid, but I don't like that overaggressiveness. Will mull over him while sleeping, then do a reread of his posts tomorrow.
3) Bookwyrm. Some of his arguments do seem like mirroring of HSL's ("Why don't you post analysis? Why do you lurk? How will we move forward?"), but I do prefer not to vote for those gunning for me, since I'm never sure how much is OMGUS and how much is proper reasons. Will try to read his posts again tomorrow as well, hopefully it will help clear if my feeling is OMGUS or proper reasons.

Off to sleep and finish digest the lunch, back in ~10 hours.
Posted May 02, 2016
vote count / votecount / vote-count

1. HijacK - 1 - CSPVG (#6),/ trentonlf (#224, #289),
2. JMich - 1 - /Dessimu (#10, #12), /trentonlf (#18, #224), wyrm (#287)
3. flubbucket - 0 - /Dessimu (#38, #69), /drealmer7 (#226, #284)
4. HypersomniacLive - 0 -
5. Bookwyrm627 - 0 -
6. Dessimu - 1 - /cristigale (#32, #141), locw (#131),
7. CSPVG - 0 -
8. drealmer7 - 3 - /drealmer7 (#9, #67), /Dessimu (#12, #33), /bookwyrm (#20, #179), babark (#26),
/Dessimu (#69, 80), flub (#204), trentonlf (#289)
9. cristigale - 0 - /Dessimu (#33), /locw (#209, #275),
10. lotsofchickenwings - 0 - /HSL (#16, #177), /Dessimu (#80, #143), /flubbucket (#120, #128),
11. a4plz - 1 - dessimu (#281),
12. babark - 1 - /flubbucket (#128, #202), /dessimu (#143, #262), HSL (#188), /wyrm (#203, #287),
13. trentonlf - 0 -

NO LYNCH - 2 - a4plz, drealmer7,

not voting - JMich, , HijacK, cristigale

closest to lynch is yours truly, drealmer, at L-4

deadline in ~23hrs
Posted May 02, 2016
avatar
cristigale: ...we need a lynch to confirm what information we will/won't get. We don't know if lynches and NK's will flip with the same information or not. With a coroner in the game, I'm not expecting much on flip but we need to confirm it.
avatar
drealmer7: I'm listening and following. Can you elaborate on why we "need" to confirm what the flips will be like? We'll find out sooner or later either way, I'm sure. Why the rush to confirm how they will be? Once we confirm how flips are for lynches, what good does that do us one way or the other and why is it more valuable to have that information D1 instead of D2? (I'm not arguing against that it will, I'm simply asking you to follow through on the logic/scenario so I can fully see what value you see in having the confirmation of flip-type sooner rather than later.)
If we get some information on the flips, roles and/or alignment, then we have something to work with tomorrow. The wagon itself also provides clues. If we vote no-lynch, we are essentially starting tomorrow in the same place as today. We'll still be guessing about the mechanics of the game, the results of the NK (assuming there is one) might give us a clue on the mechanics. Until we actually lynch someone we won't know for sure. How does being in this same situation tomorrow help us?
Posted May 02, 2016
Catching up, and doing some re-reads. Will be back a bit later.
Posted May 02, 2016
avatar
cristigale: How does being in this same situation tomorrow help us?
The wagon only provides clues if we can actually get a lynch today that is readable, but experience suggests a bunch of reasonless wagon-jumping near the deadline that makes the D1 wagon a shit-read and practically useless. I would love to avoid this, which is why I called for everyone to give a list of who they find an acceptable lynch today.

as it is, everyone has a vote placed except 3 of you, and that is at least something from them

the 3 non-voters should really be providing something at this point

cristi, you seem against no lynch, yet your non-vote and arguments do nothing to provide a reasonable alternative - at face value it seems like you're happy to lynch anyone, and in this setup, I find that scummy (dessimu too, others have not specifically chimed in to this regard, though I suppose trent has, but with sarcastic reasonlessness that is utterly unhelpful)
Posted May 02, 2016
avatar
drealmer7: cristi, you seem against no lynch, yet your non-vote and arguments do nothing to provide a reasonable alternative - at face value it seems like you're happy to lynch anyone, and in this setup, I find that scummy (dessimu too, others have not specifically chimed in to this regard, though I suppose trent has, but with sarcastic reasonlessness that is utterly unhelpful)
I am against a no-lynch. I see it to be the best course of action to lynch someone. And I made my choice of a4plz as my best try to lynch scum. If (s)he is townie, then lynch should be helpful in providing information to make better judgement D2. As simple as that.
Pages:
1
18
19
20
21
22
25
50
75
100
111
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionForum Mafia Game #40 - Wilderberry Hollow(1653 posts)(1653 posts)
(1653 posts)