I have him as "participating more than normal for his meta and then when I called him out as possible scum he turtle-headed and has been hiding" and therefore is high suspicion for me.

with the deadline a little more than 24 hours away, I'd like to hear who everyone is willing/comfortable enough to vote and lynch today - topped with raisins is always preferred, of course

in order of my vote comfort:

JMich - raisin stated above + unhelpful lurker raisin
flubbucket - seems like he's tried to antagonize and grasp a few straws but is playing it safe D1 by not pushing too hard and doing his normal scum-routine (let the townies handle killing themselves)
Dessimu - wayyyy off his meta from normal and it feels very odd + seems a bit more focused on me makes me think he's got some fear of my mad skillzzzz

I'd also like to talk more about no-lynch now that we're closer to the deadline. Yes yes, I know all of the arguments against no-lynch and what your positions are likely to be about it and I also lean that way, BUT, I still think with this different setup it is something we should talk more about and really pick apart to see if it might be a good/better idea. If you hold the same standard position and aren't willing to vote no-lynch, please don't try and squelch this discussion for those willing to talk about possibilities.

(obvious) 1st worst case scenario [which is unlikely to occur, I think] - we lynch a power role today, one gets killed tonight, we lynch one tomorrow, and that is the end of the game. I think this is unlikely to happen because if someone gets to L-1 and they claim a PR and it doesn't stink to high-heaven, I imagine we'll let them live, today, tomorrow, etc. Worst worst case would be we L-1ed the herbalist and they can't even hope for protection tonight after being outed. But, well, in this setup, I have to say, that if I am the herbalist I am probably claiming coroner if I get to L-1 in hopes the coroner picks up on the reason why I'd be doing that.

2nd worst case scenario [by odds, the most likely scenario] - we lynch vanilla today. This increases the chances for scum to successfully NK a PR, just slightly, but it will become exponential as the days go on. This is a worse vanilla lynch than a standard game and why I think no-lynch should be discussed.

unless we've got a majority of players ACTUALLY agreeing on who seems likely to be scum D1 (as opposed to the regular "oh deadline is imminent, I'ma vote ANYONE just to achieve lynch" mentality that is the majority here - just stating this for the noobs), maybe a no-lynch is more beneficial to town, especially on D1 when the things to go on are so slim.

*refresh*

I admit to having watched Friends for a couple years in the late 90s when it was on the air. I highly advise you stay away from such trash, it will corrupt your brain subversively. They are not good, funny, likable, as much as they are painted in a light to be. If you actually analyze, they're part of what is wrong with society. Vain, materialistic, narcissistic (a lot of shows put this in a negative light, this show celebrates it), too-cool douche-bags.

Dess, your attitude seems very very very different this game as opposed to other games, anything you can share about that?

ahhh, JMich was eastering, hmmmm, well that kind of changes what I said above but I'll leave it so others can see my thought processes.

unvote flubbucket
vote no lynch

*refresh*