It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionForum Mafia Game #40 - Wilderberry Hollow(1653 posts)(1653 posts)
(1653 posts)
Pages:
1
25
50
75
83
84
85
86
87
111
This is my favourite topic
Posted May 23, 2016
avatar
yogsloth: [...] Wyrm doesn't have a vote. [...]
Do you know this for a fact? How? And is that permanent? Don't answer that last one, better keep Mafia wondering.
And yeah, I wish he'd return to the game.

lotsofchickenwings is already voting JMich, remains to be seen if he's willing to vote RWarehall. But that would still mean we need two more votes to test out your plan.



avatar
flubbucket: [...] I'll look closer at things later tonight or tomorrow. [...]
The zika permitting, will we hear from you today?
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
yogsloth: [...] Wyrm doesn't have a vote. [...]
avatar
HypersomniacLive: Do you know this for a fact? How?
I don't think it particularly helps mafia to point out that he told us himself.

I legitimately don't know if he gets his vote back, but I strongly suspect the answer is "not Today anyway".
Posted May 24, 2016
I find these zika jokes rather distasteful.

Shall we make HIV jokes too?

classy
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
drealmer7: I find these zika jokes rather distasteful.

Shall we make HIV jokes too?

classy
flubbucket make a distasteful joke? Now I've seen EVERYTHING!

Hey drealmer... whaddya think? Wanna try getting a fiver on RW and JMich?
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
babark: Oh dear....
Honest mistake?
This was over 24 hours ago.

So how about you babark? Would you like to start playing yet?
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
drealmer7: I didn't say that before because I wanted to see what you happened to contribute and what others did for a little

considering you've not really helped town at all since coming into the game as far as I can see, and as a townie at this point I would figure you to have been providing a LOT more analysis and insight, you're right back up there as possible Evil for me until you do something Good

OOHHH, and I think maybe I figured trent out. In honor of me, he is RPing and directing his RP at me! which would mean he's got to be Evil!
avatar
drealmer7: I'll agree that yogs being Evil is slim chance, but I'm not discounting it all together in conjunction with the possibility that they started with 4.

If Evil started with 3 and adalia was Good and yogs is evil?...I don't see that either. Me considering yogsloth being evil is contingent on adalia also having been, and therefor leads me to the Evil started with 4 thought.

uhhh, yoggi, can you detail for us why RW is obvi-scum? that'd be helpful

I'm starting to think your fruit-basket only had prunes because Evil doesn't get spectre-abilities? and now you're just using "code" that you picked up from the previous exchange of cristi and wyrm to make it seem like you're a similar spectre to them when all you have is shit
drealmer... dreeeeeeeeeeeeeealmeeeeeeeeeeerrrr...

Come out and play, dreeeeeeeeeealmeeeeeeerrr

Come vote with us drealmer

Come vote with us

We all vote down here.
Posted May 24, 2016
I am here.
Why are we so sure about JMich and RWare? On one side there is talk of reads and "think so"s, and on the other, you talk of it being an obvious thing.
You say there are three scum and one power role between RW, babark, JMich and drealmer7. I can tell you for a fact both those things cannot be true :D.

I am curious, though...despite a very convincing story about taking one for the team and being the bait to save the power role, being this far ahead in the game, isn't it also plausible that scum decided to sacrifice one of their own to get a voice on the inside?
I mean, sure, it wastes a night for them, but that might not be an issue.

Just some thoughts!
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
yogsloth: Wanna try getting a fiver on RW and JMich?
uhhh, no.

care to actually explain to me why you find either of them likely Evil?
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
babark: I am here.
Why are we so sure about JMich and RWare? On one side there is talk of reads and "think so"s, and on the other, you talk of it being an obvious thing.
You say there are three scum and one power role between RW, babark, JMich and drealmer7. I can tell you for a fact both those things cannot be true :D.

I am curious, though...despite a very convincing story about taking one for the team and being the bait to save the power role, being this far ahead in the game, isn't it also plausible that scum decided to sacrifice one of their own to get a voice on the inside?
I mean, sure, it wastes a night for them, but that might not be an issue.

Just some thoughts!
Excellent, and thanks!

As I already noted, it is plausible Scum would nightkill one of their own it's just not probable. Scum are one kill away from the victory. What's the pro-Scum narrative for dropping the ball at the one-yard line and spotting the other team a field goal?

And no, I don't believe 100% the exorcist in in that grouping - that was a joke.

But why is it impossible? I'd really like your answer to that.
Posted May 24, 2016
Because I know what I am, and the math doesn't add up
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
babark: Because I know what I am, and the math doesn't add up
facepalm
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
babark: I am here.
Why are we so sure about JMich and RWare? On one side there is talk of reads and "think so"s, and on the other, you talk of it being an obvious thing.
You say there are three scum and one power role between RW, babark, JMich and drealmer7. I can tell you for a fact both those things cannot be true :D.

I am curious, though...despite a very convincing story about taking one for the team and being the bait to save the power role, being this far ahead in the game, isn't it also plausible that scum decided to sacrifice one of their own to get a voice on the inside?
I mean, sure, it wastes a night for them, but that might not be an issue.

Just some thoughts!
Do you think adaliabooks was Mafia or Town?
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
yogsloth: Wanna try getting a fiver on RW and JMich?
avatar
drealmer7: uhhh, no.

care to actually explain to me why you find either of them likely Evil?
So you don't want to play with us dreeeeeeeeeeealmeeeeeeeeeeerrrr?

You can plaaaaaaaaay with us........
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
HypersomniacLive: Do you think adaliabooks was Mafia or Town?
No idea. But going on the response to the last question, I guess my gut says he was town. I'm still assuming there are 3 scum out there.
Don't plan on voting for maybes this time.
Posted May 24, 2016
avatar
HypersomniacLive: Do you think adaliabooks was Mafia or Town?
avatar
babark: No idea. But going on the response to the last question, I guess my gut says he was town. I'm still assuming there are 3 scum out there.
Don't plan on voting for maybes this time.
Then how about the plan I put forward?

We never reach majority, so no risk of irreversibly lynching a Townie.

The plan only fails if:
a) One of them is Town, and
b) agent set it so that it's a Townie that gets lynched easier, which would be unfair I simply don't believe it.

No risk, no mess, all upside.

What do you think?
Pages:
1
25
50
75
83
84
85
86
87
111
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionForum Mafia Game #40 - Wilderberry Hollow(1653 posts)(1653 posts)
(1653 posts)