yogsloth: He flipped votes around a bunch, and more than that, seems to be casting shade around where it seems likely to stick.
I made a big WRRRROOOAOARRRRR adalia push and I don't like the way he rolled around in it.
[...].
"He flipped votes around a bunch" is a stretch, and I"m being kind calling it that.
Elaborate on the other two things, be specific, provide links - what's the shade he cast around? What was your big adaliabooks push?
JMich: Ah, thank you, it seems we still have trouble communicating.
No, the ~50% for town to win (40-60 may be closer) is without assuming the spectres can post mod messages.
[...]
I somehow doubt it's miscommunication issues what we have here.
Ever since your post #1012 I've been questioning you around the suggestion you made that Spectres may be messing with the mod's posts. Why would I suddenly drop that and go and ask you about the odds of Town winning in general, and unrelated to what you said in that post?
And since I still haven't gotten an answer, I'm asking you again - when you first thought about the Spectres messing with the mod's posts mechanic, and put it together with everything else we know about the game setup, the mechanics, roles, the N0 scum-chat window, did you think that Town still has a realistic chance, even if very small, of actually winning this?
JMich: My argument stems from your "You lynch me, town loses" line. It did read like a desperate attempt of the last surviving scum to be kept alive. [...]
If you thought he acted as the desperate last surviving Scum, wouldn't that mean that what you said he advocated (that crisigale and HijacK were lying Scum) was something you thought more likely to be true? And wouldn't that mean that when cristigale claimed you thought more likely that she lied? Wouldn't that mean that you thought it more likely that Mafia first let, or at least couldn't prevent, their own get lynched, and after that happened, they killed one more of their own (I assume for town-cred)?
This still sounds like what adaliabooks said in his
post #1009...
Why would you think that if Mafia was down by one end of D2, offing one more of their own in N2 and starting D3 with only one left was a sound Mafia-strategy? What is the benefit for Mafia to implement such a plan?
I'm having trouble following this... and I hope you won't call it another miscommunication.