It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
RWarehall: Of course I only have you about the 3rd most scummy at present...
avatar
Lifthrasil: And who are the lucky No.1 and No.2?
My No. 1 should be obvious (why might not be so) and No. 2 is for the same reason as Dessimu but with more experience hence scummier. Although his normal "erratic" (not sure that is the correct word) play gives me a little pause.

And no, didn't really follow the previous game that much except on the very last "day".
The thread is making me nod off

Unvote yogsloth

Vote CSPVG

CSPVG asks yogs for a plan, yogs states he has an idea to break the game open, CSPVG says not the way he wants to play it, then shortly there after (4 posts later) CSPVG states "So, O Captain Yogsloth, in which direction would you steer us, if you were so inclined?
No one has suggested anything better than offing someone based on flavour, which I do not like, so I'm willing to hear you out."

This sounds like CSPVG is wanting to go fishing and I don't like it. Whatever idea yogs has if it is discussed then information is going to be shared that is going to reveal info about town, and that is not what town needs. We need to work together to find the scum, and unfortunately day 1 there is little to no information to go on and a lynch is going to be very random.
avatar
trentonlf: and a lynch is going to be very random.
HEY ADALIA! I FOUND A RECRUIT FOR YOU!

Going to try and take another look through the thread tonight and see if anything stands out. Nothing does on memory or first read, but we'll see.
Post 28.
Post 95.
Post 148.

Unvote Dessimu.

Vote Cristigale.

Insufficient evidence.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: HEY ADALIA! I FOUND A RECRUIT FOR YOU!

.
A recruit for what? For saying that day one lynch is a random lynch? Is there any info to be had by town on day 1 to base a lynch on in most games? No, we usually look at each other and hope someone makes a some sort of slip and then they get piled on. That is very random.
Hrrrm...

Unvote: RWarehall

Vote: Cristhrasbucket
avatar
Krypsyn: Hrrrm...

Unvote: RWarehall

Vote: Cristhrasbucket
So
1. Cridtigale
2. Lift
3. Flub

Suspects in that order?
avatar
trentonlf: Suspects in that order?
Sure.
Bah... I'll just be more clear, because that is so like me. You know, gotta switch up my meta at least a little bit to keep people on their toes, right?

I want Cristigale to respond to my question to her.

I think Lifthrasil is a little scummy.

I want flubbucket to post more.

If I were voting for my suspects, I think it might go something like this:

Unvote: Cristhrasbucket
Vote: trenthrasporno

Dedoporno always seems a little scummy to me though, so maybe replace him with CSPVG? Not sure, hard for me to read CSPVG; could go either way.

In fact, I am feeling a little crazy, so maybe I should just make a real vote that might actually count? That could be fun:

Unvote: trenthrasporno
Vote: trentonlf

Meh. Wasn't as fun as I thought it would be. But, it is still better than leaving it on RWarehall. I mainly put that vote on him because I wanted him to post, and he did that days ago.
In fact, I am a little salty about a few of my other requests that went unanswered:

1) Only one person tole me what flavor of ice-cream they wanted.
2) A few people still haven't voted for anyone, as I requested.

It makes it so hard for me to get good reads when people refuse to play my games. :(

Oh well, sometimes even a refusal to answer is an answer in and of itself, I guess. Like the song goes, you can't always get what you want...

(The Rolling Stones - You Can't Always Get What You Want)
O joy, I might get to be the prettiest princess.
avatar
trentonlf: O joy, I might get to be the prettiest princess.
It is pretty super awesome! ;)
avatar
Krypsyn: I want Cristigale to respond to my question to her.
Sorry, my bad.

avatar
cristigale: I do worry when wagons form lightening fast for no apparent reason.
avatar
Krypsyn: What about when they dissipate just as lightning fast for an equal dearth of reason?
Good point. Although the votes did not change until other players started pointing out the problem. It is still the scummiest thing I have seen so far. Very little to go on this early in the game.
avatar
Dessimu: So, why do you both are so eager to suspect me, reasoning with the wagon that has already gone before you voted me? Why have not mentioned anything about my vote on Ixamyakxim? It's as if you are trying to cast suspicions on me, leaving all other indications aside.
My suspects now are Ixamyakxim, cristigale and Lifthrasil. Vote stays on Ixamyakxim.
I believe others have adequately explained why your vote on RWarehall’s wagon looked scummy. Moving your vote to someone else does not make the original act less scummy (but it may help indicate your motives.) On day One, any sort of scummy behavior is reason for a vote. With so little to go on, scummy moves stand out all the more, play-in-total is hard to judge.

As far as I can see, your original vote on lxamyakim was based purely on flavor. My voting and suspicions has nothing to do with flavor. It’s day one, so it’s hard to fault anyone for trying to find a reason to vote. But I don’t think voting on flavor is the way to go. I didn’t mention your vote on lxamyakim because it did not influence my vote one way or the other.

I can see from your later posts that you likely were just having fun with the flavor with your first vote. After the stellar play in your first game (really, best game I’ve seen from a newbie), it’s hard to know if this was an honest mistake. So I’m suspicious…just like I’m suspicious of yogs cause he’s so good at spinning things to his favor, Krypsyn cause he is always scum…flubb because he is always town, trent because I often find him suspicious, lift because I tend to agree with his reasoning (which can be cause for suspicioun), etc.

My vote is still on you because no one else has done anything I find scummier.
avatar
trentonlf: A recruit for what? For saying that day one lynch is a random lynch? Is there any info to be had by town on day 1 to base a lynch on in most games? No, we usually look at each other and hope someone makes a some sort of slip and then they get piled on. That is very random.
Really? That's rather uncharacteristic of you to "give up" like that and agree to the randomness in the end. I came to expect from you to always push for scum-hunting instead even though in some cases you end up demanding just a bit more than actually doing something about it, but that's another topic. Anyway, when did you change your mind or did I miss something?