yogsloth: Yeah, I think there's not much funny about lying to the players as moderator. Pretending to give players night actions and then simply ignoring them due to something as capricious and unfair as time stamp - and not explaining any of that - sucks. Sucks hard.
bler144: Technically if you parsed Lift's PM responses carefully, there were hints there. For example, I left my room, I had a gun - had to abort when I heard other gunfire. So it was clear that someone's kill got off before mine, and it was down to trying to puzzle out why.
That's basically what I spent all of D2 doing, and it panned out.
Which is, you know, why my team totally won that game.
Oh, no wait, we lost to the team that didn't get a single kill off and just lurked to victory by letting all the other teams blow each other up. ;)
Ixam kept so much information from us it's amazing we ended up winning. He indicated he though it might be timed based, but didn't share his PM info which would have lent credibility to his suspicion. He took the first 2-3 kill shots. We also didn't know he was a ninja or had limited use of the flip altering. Bler, when you stated in the game that we each had a ninja, I honestly thought you were lying.
Oh and I believe we got the kill the first night. :-p