RWarehall: I think the setup was okay. The one thing that might have helped, not an open setup, but tell the SK what the setup is. If he knows there is no cop and no Watchers and Trackers, he can claim anything including cop. Now that would have made it interesting...
Yes, that would have helped. It would also already have helped, if I had known that I was the murderer. As it was with one lone scum against a huge town it was impossible to win. Sure, to loose so quickly is quite some anti-accomplishment on my part. But I think with this setup and the missing information (or even contradictions/mis-understandings, as in the case of the 'alleged' bastard) it was a very one-sided game.