Posted May 13, 2019
Bookwyrm627: 3 mafia means game could end (barring role intervention) on N2.
Make it 2 mafia and maybe let them talk during role selection. Boom, slightly more power without town only getting 1 mislynch (barring role intervention).
Therefore, it is only 2 mafia. Quid pro quo, ipso facto, proof done. Lets move on.
There were 2 (one, two: two) role interventions last game, where town was defense-weak (conditional doctor, machismo townie, 1 useless player who was policy-lynched D1...). In a game where Town can have a doctor, cop, roleblocker, vig and JOAT on top of that, it's prsctically guaranteed the game won't go lynch-NK-lynch-NK... etc. Town can easyly get more than 1 mislynch chance. Make it 2 mafia and maybe let them talk during role selection. Boom, slightly more power without town only getting 1 mislynch (barring role intervention).
Therefore, it is only 2 mafia. Quid pro quo, ipso facto, proof done. Lets move on.
Nolo contendre, habeas corpus, proof undone. I'd rather assume there 3 mafioso and have it turn out wrong than the other way round. I'll agree though with the "lets move on".