JoeSapphire: I think he mentioned this trip in the sign-up thread too...
dedoporno: I know, that's my point. That he won't be available until almost deadline which is bad for us for different reasons depending on his alignment.
hm... it seemed like you were suggesting it might indicate he was mafia, but okay.
ZFR: Joe, and Pooka, why assume 2 scum only? I'll admit my first impression was 3, but thats pribably because it was 3 in every game I played so far, except Shodan's Children.
My 'template' is that a 12 player game has 3 mafias, a 9 player game has 2 mafias. 10 is closer to 2, also with the possibility of killing powers in the game, it makes more sense to have the smaller amount of mafia. If I was running this set up I'd have two.
Microfish_1: Any claims that
all town have "bad guy" names are blatantly false.
Was such a claim made? Where did you get this from?
I checked the role list again to see if there the role that gives mafia day chat (comms manager? the word enabler comes to mind but that doesn't seem right.) Anyway there isn't one so... hm...
yogsloth: I can tell you my character name has fuck-all to do with my role
flubbucket: Or maybe it's this.
My character name is quite appropriate.
Interesting that you're having a go at Yogsloth - he's been on my mind while I've been away from internet and one of the things that I kept coming back to was the little
"Yogsloth: I vote flub
flub: don't vote me I want to live!
Yogsloth: okay then... "
[I have interpolated this event]
I was thinking it odd and maybe indicated you were both on the same team, but now that I say that out loud (as it were) seems a bit stupid...
Then there's Flub in 108 doing some serious prodding and investigating? The contrast from the persona he tends to put on has got me more than shocked, I'm...
flubbergasted!! But I've just noticed that the people he's prodding is bookwyrm and yogsloth - yogsloth's voting bookwyrm for unspecified reason, bookwyrm's voting flubbucket for... *goes to check* not voting. Which is maybe significant?
I'm tying my brain in knots...
I'm still reading bookwyrm with vaguely good vibes, but I'm losing faith in my instinct.
So I think I'm voting for Yogsloth,
Yogsloth's self-destructive bit, along with thing yogsloth-bookwyrm-flubbucket thing (that maybe I'm imagining??) PLUS the fact that the other person voting for Yogsloth is Pooka and I'm fairly happy with Pooka being town
I feel a bit stupid voting for Yogsloth what with his whole "look at me look at me" thing, but I'd be stupid to not vote him because of a double-bluff wouldn't I?..
unvote bookwyrm vote Yogsloth For attention of everyone Does anybody else fancy doing a "I think the mafia is 1, 2, (3)"? They might be enlightening
I'm currently tempted by the idea that Yogsloth, Flub, Bookwyrm are the mafias, but probably not...