It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionForum Mafia #38 - Murder on the Wing (game thread)(1026 posts)(1026 posts)
(1026 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
50
60
61
62
63
64
69
This is my favourite topic
Posted April 02, 2016
I've played around long enough...

One of the claims made a serious mistake...

So let's look at what we have:
Drealmer - You claim to have investigated Trentonlf and find he is completely innocent and definitely not a SK.
You investigate me, find me obsessed with fire and rage and definitely a SK. (I'm pyrophobic, afraid of fire, hence why I hoarded the fire extinguishers). Notice how the read is completely the opposite of the truth...
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
RWarehall: I've played around long enough...

One of the claims made a serious mistake...

So let's look at what we have:
Drealmer - You claim to have investigated Trentonlf and find he is completely innocent and definitely not a SK.
You investigate me, find me obsessed with fire and rage and definitely a SK. (I'm pyrophobic, afraid of fire, hence why I hoarded the fire extinguishers). Notice how the read is completely the opposite of the truth...
You're correct

Unvote flub
Vote drealmer
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
RWarehall: I've played around long enough...

One of the claims made a serious mistake...

So let's look at what we have:
Drealmer - You claim to have investigated Trentonlf and find he is completely innocent and definitely not a SK.
You investigate me, find me obsessed with fire and rage and definitely a SK. (I'm pyrophobic, afraid of fire, hence why I hoarded the fire extinguishers). Notice how the read is completely the opposite of the truth...
which is why I believe all investigations are false and wasn't like "OMG he's lying he's actually a serial killer!" If I hadn't gotten the read I did on trent, I wouldn't have been able to discern this, but this is what makes it clear.
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
cristigale: ...
avatar
drealmer7: or maybe (one of?) the bastard element(s) is mafia doesn't know they are mafia, and you are killing unknowingly and are actually mafia?
If that's true then bler didn't just use deceptive PM info, he outright lied about my role.

Again, why have a backup town surgeon, if there is no town surgeon? No one else fits the bill.
Posted April 02, 2016
To continue...
Notice Bookwyrm's read...
CSPVG - decapitations, blah blah, obviously scum

And then we come to CSPVG's read: Hunter - couldn't hurt a fly, definitely town...

But shouldn't he really get a true read of "couldn't hurt a fly" for a Survivor? Hunter claims this is correct... yet the Town part is wrong by Hunter's own admission...

Not to mention how Hunter claims to win by surviving to today...so already won...because somehow we will find out he survived (even a lynch somehow) and we won't find him missing until dawn of Day 4?

I mean...you won already, right Hunter? You want a quick lynch to make sure you win just to make sure no one can Dayvig you, right?

Vote Hunter

If Cristie and Drealmer vote right now, you can even vote yourself and ensure your victory!
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
RWarehall: I've played around long enough...

One of the claims made a serious mistake...

So let's look at what we have:
Drealmer - You claim to have investigated Trentonlf and find he is completely innocent and definitely not a SK.
You investigate me, find me obsessed with fire and rage and definitely a SK. (I'm pyrophobic, afraid of fire, hence why I hoarded the fire extinguishers). Notice how the read is completely the opposite of the truth...
avatar
drealmer7: which is why I believe all investigations are false and wasn't like "OMG he's lying he's actually a serial killer!" If I hadn't gotten the read I did on trent, I wouldn't have been able to discern this, but this is what makes it clear.
All investigations aren't false though CSPVG got the right results on me and I am town like he concluded on day 1.
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
RWarehall: ...
gosh you had me scared, I was like, "it's obviously hunter we should go for, how are you missing it, RW?!"

yes, I was thinking this as well (town read vs. neutral claim) and found it glaring

vote hunternumbers
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: All investigations aren't false though CSPVG got the right results on me and I am town like he concluded on day 1.
So Hunter, you now claim to be a "Town Survivor" unlike your "Neutral Survivor" claim in post 752?
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: All investigations aren't false though CSPVG got the right results on me and I am town like he concluded on day 1.
avatar
RWarehall: So Hunter, you now claim to be a "Town Survivor" unlike your "Neutral Survivor" claim in post 752?
I meant town as in one of the good guys. And why would a vote on me by myself even count as legit?
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: And why would a vote on me by myself even count as legit?
because you can vote yourself in any mafia game and it counts
Posted April 02, 2016
It wouldn't be the first time. I've seen a few self-lynches as crazy as that seems.
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: And why would a vote on me by myself even count as legit?
avatar
drealmer7: because you can vote yourself in any mafia game and it counts
Pretty sure voting myself would go against the survivor thing I've got going. It doesn't make sense.

@cristi now we've got the scum team, rw and drealmer.
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
drealmer7: because you can vote yourself in any mafia game and it counts
avatar
Hunter65536: Pretty sure voting myself would go against the survivor thing I've got going. It doesn't make sense.

@cristi now we've got the scum team, rw and drealmer.
so what do you make of my claim?
Posted April 02, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: Pretty sure voting myself would go against the survivor thing I've got going. It doesn't make sense.

@cristi now we've got the scum team, rw and drealmer.
avatar
drealmer7: so what do you make of my claim?
What's there to make of it, you're lying like rw pointed out a while ago and then he mysteriously voted me.
Posted April 02, 2016
<The I'm going to bed vote count>

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

1. Drealmer (1) - Hunter
2. Krypsyn
5. RW
6. Flub
10. cristi
11. Hunter (2) - RW, Drealmer

Not voting: krypsyn, flub, cristi

You have a deadline - it is 1:59pm PST on Monday, April 4.
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
50
60
61
62
63
64
69
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionForum Mafia #38 - Murder on the Wing (game thread)(1026 posts)(1026 posts)
(1026 posts)