It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionForum Mafia #38 - Murder on the Wing (game thread)(1026 posts)(1026 posts)
(1026 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
49
50
51
52
53
60
69
This is my favourite topic
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: Well, THAT'S an interesting wrinkle, and an alignment change would certainly account for the firm bastard mod territory. Not sure what to make of it. If the SK joins us, then he wins with Town, right?

What happens if you visit Mafia? Any kind of clue, or is it the same as visiting town?

Leap of Faith time. I'm going to trust Trent, at least for now, about being town. Two insane cops would be strong, while a naive cop + paranoid cop would be a strong handicap with two kills each night. Taken together, that means I'm probably insane (quite possibly me as well as Danny-me). I think that indicates CSPVG was also insane, with us being a reflection. That means Hunter is scum.

Unvote Drealmer.
Vote Hunter.

Hunter, I'd like to hear you claim after all.
I don't know alignment of who I visit, all I know is if they are the SK or not.
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: Well, THAT'S an interesting wrinkle, and an alignment change would certainly account for the firm bastard mod territory. Not sure what to make of it. If the SK joins us, then he wins with Town, right?

What happens if you visit Mafia? Any kind of clue, or is it the same as visiting town?

Leap of Faith time. I'm going to trust Trent, at least for now, about being town. Two insane cops would be strong, while a naive cop + paranoid cop would be a strong handicap with two kills each night. Taken together, that means I'm probably insane (quite possibly me as well as Danny-me). I think that indicates CSPVG was also insane, with us being a reflection. That means Hunter is scum.

Unvote Drealmer.
Vote Hunter.

Hunter, I'd like to hear you claim after all.
I'm a neutral survivor, I should get to day 3 to win. And I have double vote power on day 42.
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: I'm a neutral survivor, I should get to day 3 to win. And I have double vote power on day 42.
What's your back story?
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: ......<snip>.........
I think that indicates CSPVG was also insane, with us being a reflection. That means Hunter is scum.
......<snip>.........
Any opinions regarding Krypsyn and me??

One good the other bad??
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: What's your back story?
Been here a few weeks and figured a way to get out but for that to happen I need to stay alive a little longer. That's the primary reason I didn't protest your idea of lynching me on day 3 just to identify your sanity, at the same time I couldn't outright say that was fine with me so I acted like I was mildly concerned.
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: What's your back story?
avatar
Hunter65536: Been here a few weeks and figured a way to get out but for that to happen I need to stay alive a little longer. That's the primary reason I didn't protest your idea of lynching me on day 3 just to identify your sanity, at the same time I couldn't outright say that was fine with me so I acted like I was mildly concerned.
How do you suppose CSPVG's poison allegation figures into all of this??
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
flubbucket: How do you suppose CSPVG's poison allegation figures into all of this??
No idea myself, no mention of poison anywhere in my PM.
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: ......<snip>.........
I think that indicates CSPVG was also insane, with us being a reflection. That means Hunter is scum.
......<snip>.........
avatar
flubbucket: Any opinions regarding Krypsyn and me??

One good the other bad??
Hard to say. You were bread crumbing Miller before the cop reveals, and continued afterward. I could see you doing that as either alignment, though obviously risky as Scum. Krypsyn could have easily piggybacked off your claim while citing duality once you revealed the bread crumbs. He is certainly smart enough to do so.

However, Miller isn't exactly a strong claim for town to make, and I could easily see one or two Millers in the setup to help the insane cops figure out they were insane. Three deaths per cycle with two cops in the mix? It will become obvious (to the cops at least) very quickly that they aren't sane. I could see the SK flipping as the other doctor; he started crazy. SK has a decent win chance with the extra "path" to win, town has a decent win chance (especially if they convert the SK), and 2 kills a night from low starting numbers with 3 scum mean a decent win chance for them too. Balanced at the faction level.

I have a question for you: are you reasonably convinced that Krypsyn is a reflection of you?
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: Been here a few weeks and figured a way to get out but for that to happen I need to stay alive a little longer. That's the primary reason I didn't protest your idea of lynching me on day 3 just to identify your sanity, at the same time I couldn't outright say that was fine with me so I acted like I was mildly concerned.
Do you leave the game on Day 3?
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: Do you leave the game on Day 3?
From what I understand dawn of day 4 you'll notice me missing, remember how I said this (in flavor post 487)

"All right, people," says Hunter, reluctantly, "if we're going to do this, let's do it right. Go back to your rooms and get anything that can be used as a weapon. Meet back here in...oh say 20 minutes. I'll use this mop to keep him corralled in there."
Well the escape point is near it, so I sent you away to make my preparations.
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: From what I understand dawn of day 4 you'll notice me missing, remember how I said this (in flavor post 487)
So your objective is to survive the entirety of Day 3 and Night 3, not just make it TO Day 3?
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
trentonlf: I'm the town psychiatrist. I get to visit one person a night and if they are a serial killer I cure them.
I don't believe you.

avatar
trentonlf: I visited Krypsyn on night one and found no evidence that he was the serial kill.
What sort of evidence were you looking for? What did you find?
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Bookwyrm627: So your objective is to survive the entirety of Day 3 and Night 3, not just make it TO Day 3?
Night 3 not included, even if I am taken to lynch on day 3 I can escape is what I understood. The alone time in lynch place being key factor here. I can get that by being lynched as well as during someone else's lynch. If someone has day vig (not the standard lynch) and uses it on me then I'm toast even on day 3.
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: From what I understand dawn of day 4 you'll notice me missing, remember how I said this (in flavor post 487)
avatar
Bookwyrm627: So your objective is to survive the entirety of Day 3 and Night 3, not just make it TO Day 3?
Bookwyrm - so when you received a read. Did the mod state the alignment specifically, or did he leave it to your interpretation?
Posted March 31, 2016
avatar
Hunter65536: Night 3 not included, even if I am taken to lynch on day 3 I can escape is what I understood. The alone time in lynch place being key factor here. I can get that by being lynched as well as during someone else's lynch. If someone has day vig (not the standard lynch) and uses it on me then I'm toast even on day 3.
Interesting. Don't know what to make of this, either.

avatar
RWarehall: Bookwyrm - so when you received a read. Did the mod state the alignment specifically, or did he leave it to your interpretation?
The read was specific. There was no interpretation on Wyrm's part necessary.

If CSPVG and I are insane, then I have no idea how a neutral scan would show up. I could see an SK returning as Town (since SK is specifically anti-town), but I have no idea about a a town-agnostic neutral. Both of my reads are Mafia, not just Scum or Not Town.

-----

Just scanned the most recent "Willing to Vote for" for each player, as best I could tell. No Lynch it is, then!

Trent:
Bookwyrm
RW
Drealmer

Hunter:
Krypsyn
Drealmer
Cristigale

RW:
Flub
Krypsyn
Trent

Cristi:
*Drealmer
**Trent (might not be back to change her vote)

Flub:
Trent

Krypsyn:
Trent
Cristi

Drealmer:
RW
Wyrm
No Lynch
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
49
50
51
52
53
60
69
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionForum Mafia #38 - Murder on the Wing (game thread)(1026 posts)(1026 posts)
(1026 posts)