So you read two files and they both presented bad people that you knew were mafia, and both ended up being town. If you are an insane cop we can actually use that as you would just go off of the opposite of what you read. But, if you actually do read everyone as mafia no matter what I don't think it does any good for you to read anymore files.

With everything that's happened how do we take JMich being poison immune and Hunter's file mentioning poison gas. Is it another false trail?

I thought today you would be the lynch for sure, and I was wondering why you sacrificed yourself like that yesterday if you were scum. Now I'm concerned this is some sort of mental hospital and you are insane but still town.



How would mafia accidentally kill their traitor? If they thought dedo was mafia they would not have targeted him so how could they have killed him?

Read the description of Traitor in the Mafia wiki. Many variations, but the essentials are that you have an ally who knows who the mafia are and is trying to steer lynches clear of them, but the Mafia do not know the name of their own traitor.

Did anyone else dream of a gunshot? D2 flavor indicates JMich lost a lot of blood but does not indicate what caused it.

He was a back-up surgeon, which means we should have a surgeon. Maybe he was shot and the surgeon tried to save him.

Dream about it? Nope. I was dreaming of eating a rabbit omelet; Or "Thumper In a Blanket", as I like to call it. I like to imagine kicking as I swallow. More fun that way.

I would be fitting in this game if the SK didn't even realize he was a SK until now as he was just a compulsive doctor and didn't know he would kill his target.

Of course he could also not be compulsive and town and could stop trying to protect people...

Since Traitor is described as 1/2 a scum role, I'm leaning to 2 scum remaining with the sk/insane doctor as a possible twist.

According to the wiki, if a poisoner had an action N1, we would not see the effects until N2.

A shot could have been blocked. That'd be a lot for one night.

If we have an arsonist, they might be limited shots, even nights, or some type of restriction.

With 11 original players and a a confirmed town mentioned in the signup thread, I could see up to four scum if
the numbers were 2-1-1.

@RWarehall - you said "it seems Bler threw around a lot of anti-thisorthat powers which are meaningless"
(Emphasis added)
Are you aware of other arsonist related powers beside your own? What did you mean by "a lot" of powers?

Or a kipper. Maybe.

Are you aware of other arsonist related powers besides your own in the game? It sounded like you had knowledge about more arsonist related roles in the game besides your own.

And, of course, the above should have read "Poison-Immune" not resistant.

The only difference is my power has a fixed number of uses equal to the number of fire extinguishers I stashed away. I was otherwise doing my best to take one for the team as a good Vanilla.

So is this a mass claim on Day Two??? Great -_-

I essentially already claimed day 1. It was very clear my role was not doctor, cop, tracker, etc.

I felt clarifying further was important as it seems this game is about wading through Bler's deceptions to find the truth.

Now you know why I did so. Because it was the only way (besides pure chance) to make my power useful and help town...

My, it look like everything’s rosy. =D

Bookwyrm627.....you're reading/rereading right??

Good God I hope not, might as well just hand the win to scum if we do that. The roles seem to be so unusual almost any claim would be believable, then where would we be. Scum would know who to target and we would still be wondering who to lynch.