Enlightening.

How about you? Care to explain YOUR vote?

...






No, I'm kidding. But do I really need to? If anybody cares, I'd be perfectly happy with Leonard as well. adalia holds the edge for me currently, but I'd take either.

Adalia? Advocating for just getting on with the lynch and killing someone? Perish the thought!

I've been slack, and thus am still 3 pages or so behind; most of Leonard thus far has struck me as more confused than insidious. Maybe my opinion on one or both will change when I finally finish catching up.

I fully expected this when P1na flipped scum. The only defence I can give is riddled with WIFOM (why would I say what I said if I was his buddy, knowing how he would flip) so I'm not sure it's worth bothering (beyond what I said in the previous parenthesis).

All I can say is I said and did what I felt was necessary. I had no real read on P1na, he could just as easily have been town floundering after making a joke that went bad as scum. But I felt the reasoning of those pushing his wagon was flawed.
Despite that, I would have hammered anyway. We saw last game how a bad day 1 can wreck the game for town, and there wasn't time to lynch someone else before the deadline. So I did what I thought was best and hammered the lynch we did have. And (short of having a cop read on him) I would have done so whatever my position on him was, even if I had had him leaning town. A flip, and a confirmed townie, is more useful than one you think might be town but aren't sure.

Funnily enough, I found JMich quite suspicious after the flip for having said he would hammer but holding back, yet he has turned up dead, and without a flip to boot. I think there is something fishy going on here.

Well, yeah.

It's JMich. He's sleeping with them.

LOL, that same thing crossed my mind when he said that too.

No he's not... we found his body. :P

It was pretty explicit that JMich himself was NOT sleeping with the fishes. You know something we don't? :P

And to answer your previous question, while technically you don't need to explain your vote, I for one would like you to do so. You're too slippery (fish joke!) not to try and pin down on occasion.

Woohoo one down!

Also...

Vote Bookwyrm

I think you screwed up yesterday and you knew about the no flip in advance AND you seemed to be trying to pry the role of coroner out of yogsloth.

Aside from this, which is weird (I'm guessing adalia just misunderstood how coroner works?) what about adalia has been scummy? I... feel pretty good about him to be honest.

I could get on board with leonard as well - I don't know what it is about his posts but a lot of them don't sit well with me. The only thing that really screamed something was off though was his vote at the end of day yesterday. Seriously p1na was at lynch -1 or -2 and he votes flubb? I can see no other point for that vote than to either restart a previous wagon when he saw a scumbuddy was in trouble (p1na) or to "get on record" having a vote on flubb in the event that he (leonard) and flub are scumbuddies.

Or it could be precisely what it was: a townie narrowing down the possibilities and then asking a game relevant question based on what was left. If, you know, you want to consider alternatives.

Ditto.

And to answer your rhetorical question: Nope.

So this is the point where I just post "Heh." and then everyone thinks I'm town?
Or is that only something anti-hippies do?
I know, I know, I'm exaggerating. But refusing to answer questions doesn't help us.

As for the fact that I was utterly and completely wrong about P1na, well... I just never expected that mafia would do anything like that. I cannot understand why he did it.

What else am I supposed to do if I don't think the current wagon is a good lynch? Just not vote? That is silly sir!

Looks like mafia was really afraid of JMich's analytical skills.


[emphasis added]

I'd like a source to that, please. Because I could not find anything stating this, even as an exception, while what you suppose to also be an option seems to be how the role works.
Seems to me like an attempt to steer attention away from you, before it builds up too much, and you can't handle it. Same goes for your first post of Today. Reminds me of something yogsloth had said about you in the dead thread of RW's game.

I have to agree with trentonlf, don't buy that "you know me, I’m all for lynching, but this is sooo wrong, poor P1na, he was just joking around. *sigh* You leave me no choice, I have to hammer, but it's still sooo wrong, Look what you're making me do now!"

But please, enlighten us - what pressure exactly was he under when he (false)claimed at L-6?



[emphasis added]

Would you mind telling us how he'd know that? Just to be clear about what you're implying here.



What exactly is it that you never expected mafia to do? False claim Town Vanilla?

Make a joke about wanting to work with the mafia and wanting to have a drink, was what I would never expect a mafia to do.
You're just playing with me here, obviously mafia would false claim town vanilla >_>