It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
Catventurer: This game is so boring....
You could have answered my earlier questions to alleiviating some of that boredom. It seemed you didn't want to reply to me much in game. If you are towni then you didn't exactly help our side if you were doing such.

avatar
mchack: Like I said I feel like their self vote pointed more to that of a frustrated townie, but at this point I feel this is the only wagon that could gain enough traction before the deadline.
You and bucktooth say similar things in posting #262 and #263. Very odd that being so back to back with similar sentiments. Yes the words are wise and plan is sound given no other good wagons at deadine, but my gut wonders if one of you is a scum trying to gain townie points and hide among the godd guys by doing such.

avatar
mchack: yes. ok, you get town points from me for that. Scum wouldn't need to do that. Scum could just lean back and enjoy the end of day.
But if they lean back too much then they appear more scummy. Aha!

avatar
PookaMustard: Well I act with my gut, and my gut tells me Fark is Catholic and not some Reformer thinking ahead of the curve. In a normal game of Mafia, to hell with voting Farky if I'm honest, being on a wagon that I have strong conviction it belongs to a Townie is just rewarding scum.
Your posting here and hammering me puts points to you being townie I think. Wish I was scum so you wouldn't feeling so bad about voting me out but alas I am not being scum.

avatar
Lifthrasil: Fark was a Catholic Messenger (Town PR), and his voting and electing rights are withdrawn. He may (and is expected to) continue to participate in the game, but cannot use his power anymore and can't be elected.
Haaaaaaaaa, you guys (and gals) suck! I am so outta here, until I post again to keep active that is!
avatar
mchack: Hope you're not too frustrated. I pledge here and now, that should I be the next town mislynch, I'll continue playing and try and not take it personally, since I asked that of two others by now, that I pushed a wagon on.
I am being somewhat frustrated but at least I can still posting here when usually I can not. No promises but I will try to posting still to the game.

avatar
mchack: now that we know the messenger is/was town are you still thinking that the prankster is town aswell? What do you think they were telling you?
My feeling that post is more likely being made up by a scum!catventurer. Why? Partly because of their posting so far and my gut, and also because I would rather believe their play (not replying to my questions much before hammer or stuffs like posting#253) is due to being crafty scum and not unhelpful townie.

avatar
mchack: So you were just saying Farky is town by analyzing his writing pattern or are you implying there's another player in this game you suspect is town? Please use simple words so even I can get it.
Perhaps read posting#204?
Pooka
Hmm. Not much on D1, but I think that was usual for D1 for him. Got things confused, maybe some tactic to have something to post as scum?
avatar
PookaMustard: They seem rusty as hell if they missed bits of the opening posts. Like Farky used up his role on the mistaken believe that it's a Catholic only role (this only gives him more Town rep though!?).
What did you mean with „used up his role? It wasn’t a one-shot.

Naturally not a fan of:
avatar
PookaMustard: So really, it all comes down to scene? I'm not really a big fan of voting anyone else, though, at least not at the moment.
Like Catventurer explained: Investigation of inactive players doesn’t help.


bucktoothgamer
I like his response to Joppo in 99.
avatar
joppo: I find this post pretty scummy TBF. "Ohnoes, there's a train leading, let's make sure votes are split onto a second train, hopefully leading Town to indecision and getting us a NoLynch".
If we were in the last 48 hours of this Day I would declare you the first scum right here and now. As it is, if we happen to investigate Micro and find scum you're certainly his buddy.
The fact that you and Micro later pile up on CatV (posts #65-67) doesn't make you appear any less connected either.

Now I am torn. Between this pair I think Bucktooth is far scummier than Micro, but Micro does have votes, Bucktooth does not.
(sigh)
Vote Micro
avatar
bucktoothgamer: By that logic that I would have been scum no matter which way I put a vote at that point

Vote Micro? "Oh man scumbuddy is going down, better bury myself in the wagon to save face when he flips"
Vote Pooka? "Lets jump on another train to hopefully take them down before micro goes down"
Vote {Insert any other name} "Lets make something up and hope it sticks and pulls votes away from micro"

The game was moving pretty slow at that point so I figured a couple trains to get something moving would be beneficial to the game to get some further digging going.

My last vote for Cat was due in part due to their appeal for Popedom to get the game over with since everyone seems to lost interest. This could have been a joke of course, but the paranoid in me also sees that she has been one of the more active players in a game so far that has had a slow start due to the holiday. A scum who takes command of a slow game early to give off the impression of "Townie taking charge to get things done" would be a wise strategy so far, and I'm having a hard time at this moment seeing it any other way.
Other than that, I can’t place him.


mchack
Still not a fan of charts.
Showed up late to help investigate micro. Like a few others, I like post 181.
avatar
mchack: I pledge here and now, that should I be the next town mislynch, I'll continue playing and try and not take it personally, since I asked that of two others by now, that I pushed a wagon on.
Eh, LAMIST? Not sure that qualifies.
Thanks for the welcome though.


trentonlf
Seems his usual self.
Voting Farky for wanting to invastigate an inactive player
avatar
trentonlf: Right now I am leaning toward FarkyTheDog, him trying to justify removing someone that has given ZERO information because it's the easiest thing to do rubs be wrong.
and not reacting to Pookas 257 seems odd though.
Plus he’s a very good player and already fooled me once as scum.


yogsloth
He seems awefully relaxed. The one time I played and he was scum, he was very aggressive. Maybe he changed tactics? Or he is just being himself. It’s been a while since I played.


Joppo
Not a fan of calling bucktoothgamer scummy:
avatar
bucktoothgamer: Looks like we have a couple trains forming with the all of a sudden interest in investigating micro.
Let's even up the score and see where any potential allegiances lie

Vote pooka
avatar
joppo: I find this post pretty scummy TBF. "Ohnoes, there's a train leading, let's make sure votes are split onto a second train, hopefully leading Town to indecision and getting us a NoLynch".
If we were in the last 48 hours of this Day I would declare you the first scum right here and now. As it is, if we happen to investigate Micro and find scum you're certainly his buddy.
The fact that you and Micro later pile up on CatV (posts #65-67) doesn't make you appear any less connected either.

Now I am torn. Between this pair I think Bucktooth is far scummier than Micro, but Micro does have votes, Bucktooth does not.
(sigh)
Vote Micro
Well, he preferred bucktoothgamer, but went with micro to not open another train, I guess, so consistent with line of thought of thinking it scummy.


Catventurer
Seems towny, but
avatar
Catventurer: Okay. Fine.

UNVOTE Fark

Only because I'm convinced there will never be enough votes to investigate no regardless of what I think.
Find me someone to vote for that isn't myself.
rubs me the wrong way.
Like, „that is who I want out and I’m not looking any further myself, you do it“.

Post 253
avatar
FarkyTheDog: When you are having a moment, who would be your second biggest suspect after me and why?
avatar
Catventurer: My Top Scum Picks
1 > FarkyTheDog
2 > FarkyTheDog1932
3 > Fark-9191932
4 > Cardinal South
Also falls in this category.

And considering she went after Farky for wanting to lynch an inactive player it is a little strange to only get that
avatar
Catventurer: This game is so boring....
as a post after Pookas 257.


I also want a Pope. Of course, it has to be the right Pope.


For now
Investigate Pooka
That's not what I was expecting. Sorry Farky, I really thought you were scum.

Welcome FlockeShnee to the game, thanks for stepping in for Scene (I sure hope he is ok).

avatar
FlockeSchnee: Just real quick, before I try to put my thoughts into words:
Oh, random investigation choice would mean it could hit a Reformer. Well, question would be, if it’s worth hoping for that. We are at 5/3 already, not so bad odds, but we’d have to find the accuser first. And assuming we find him right away, that would be 5/2, so not so good odds after all.
I am not fully understanding what you are getting at here. Are you concerned about investigating people because they might not be scum? We don't have any way of finding out who is scum except by voting so I am not sure what you are getting at.
LOL, teach me to not forget to refresh before posting because Flocke cleared up my confusion about his first post. If you are asking why I didn’t say anything to Pooka about his comment about Scene is because they were going at each other early on until Scene disappeared and I thought Pooka was referencing that.

Trying to post this as I’m driving, don’t recommend…
avatar
mchack: now that we know the messenger is/was town are you still thinking that the prankster is town aswell? What do you think they were telling you?
Yes. I'm also fairly confident that it's someone that reads the thread and doesn't skim. I think they saw me saying that my cat hates forum time and did their prank as a way to say, "Please be distracted by all these cats that I'm giving you."

If you look at things objectively, people have been just hiding behind me all game. I need to be distracted by all those cats so that they will have no choice except to participate more and stop using me as a crutch.
avatar
Catventurer: This game is so boring....
avatar
FarkyTheDog: You could have answered my earlier questions to alleiviating some of that boredom. It seemed you didn't want to reply to me much in game. If you are towni then you didn't exactly help our side if you were doing such.
No. Since I thought you were scum, that would just be putting up a hit list if I was wrong. Instead of demanding that I alone solve the game, why aren't you demanding more of the people that have been very non-committal the entire game.
avatar
Catventurer: Yes. I'm also fairly confident that it's someone that reads the thread and doesn't skim.
Except one could've picked up on such things re: your posts while skimming as well.

avatar
Catventurer: No. Since I thought you were scum, that would just be putting up a hit list if I was wrong. Instead of demanding that I alone solve the game, why aren't you demanding more of the people that have been very non-committal the entire game.
You were one of the few who had a laser focus on me for awhile. In order to help me play the game (with your insight if you're townie and also helping me to be puzzling out your alignment a bit) I asked for your second most likely suspect and why. As I said, either you're crafty scum or a townie being unhelpful by not helping another townie (myself) play better and puzzle out the game.
EBWOP
At some point I would have asked others for the same infos I asked cat for, had I not been hammered.

avatar
FlockeSchnee: Catventurer
Seems towny, but
avatar
Catventurer: Okay. Fine.

UNVOTE Fark

Only because I'm convinced there will never be enough votes to investigate no regardless of what I think.
Find me someone to vote for that isn't myself.
avatar
FlockeSchnee: rubs me the wrong way.
Like, „that is who I want out and I’m not looking any further myself, you do it“.

Post 253
avatar
Catventurer: My Top Scum Picks
1 > FarkyTheDog
2 > FarkyTheDog1932
3 > Fark-9191932
4 > Cardinal South
avatar
FlockeSchnee: Also falls in this category.
I honestly hope cat really is crafty scum at this point. If they are then I saying to them 'well played'.
Sorry Fark. Unfortunately my gut was correct, and furthers my track record of seeing self votes leading more to frustrated townies than scum making the ultimate bluff.

Since I've gone against my gut twice now and both turned up town it's time to stop fighting it and go back to basics.

Vote Cat

Argueably one of the most involved in the game so far and her hunches keep pulling up town. It will annoy me to no end if I'm right, but if I am right she deserves a medal for the performance she's given so far.
avatar
FarkyTheDog: You were one of the few who had a laser focus on me for awhile. In order to help me play the game (with your insight if you're townie and also helping me to be puzzling out your alignment a bit) I asked for your second most likely suspect and why. As I said, either you're crafty scum or a townie being unhelpful by not helping another townie (myself) play better and puzzle out the game.
You've been tunnel vision on me from day one. Accusing me of being scum and making demands of me that you wouldn't make of anyone else. But you know what. Let's all investigate me so that Farky can see that he was wrong about me all along.

VOTE Catventurer

You need to move on to other people after this.
Sad to see micro and Farky as stumps already, but it is nice, they can still state their opinions.

Three players, that are new to me.


@Lift:
If I elect someone and change my mind without having another candidate for it, can I at any time self-elect again?


avatar
trentonlf: Welcome FlockeShnee to the game, thanks for stepping in for Scene (I sure hope he is ok).

avatar
FlockeSchnee: Just real quick, before I try to put my thoughts into words:
Oh, random investigation choice would mean it could hit a Reformer. Well, question would be, if it’s worth hoping for that. We are at 5/3 already, not so bad odds, but we’d have to find the accuser first. And assuming we find him right away, that would be 5/2, so not so good odds after all.
avatar
trentonlf: I am not fully understanding what you are getting at here. Are you concerned about investigating people because they might not be scum? We don't have any way of finding out who is scum except by voting so I am not sure what you are getting at.
Thanks.
I was contemplating, if a random investigation, if no majority is reached could benefit town, but the odds seems against that.


avatar
yogsloth: I'm sorry, I know I'm struggling here

This format is just really strange, it's just difficult to figure out what to do without regular mechanics
I can relate. The mechanics are very different. Not that I was that good with the ordinary forum mafia mechanics. Still, this looks, like it’s gonna end bad for town.


avatar
mchack:
Is this your first time playing mafia/werewolf, or do you have some experience already?


avatar
Catventurer: VOTE Catventurer
Really? Another self-voter? I kind of expect that from Farky, but you? It looks like you try to benefit from Farky flipping town afterwards.

Can anyone, who has played with Catventurer before, tell me, what her playstyle is usually like?
avatar
Catventurer: VOTE Catventurer
avatar
FlockeSchnee: Really? Another self-voter? I kind of expect that from Farky, but you? It looks like you try to benefit from Farky flipping town afterwards.

Can anyone, who has played with Catventurer before, tell me, what her playstyle is usually like?
This is not a "woe is me vote." Accusing me of being unhelpful when others have been barely posting is just flat out rude, especially when there were two substitutions for non-participation. If there was a night phase, I could go be angry at everyone for a few days to try to get past that but there isn't. At this point, I'm just offended to the point that I actively want to be voted out.
avatar
Catventurer: This is not a "woe is me vote." Accusing me of being unhelpful when others have been barely posting is just flat out rude, especially when there were two substitutions for non-participation. If there was a night phase, I could go be angry at everyone for a few days to try to get past that but there isn't. At this point, I'm just offended to the point that I actively want to be voted out.
Well, apparently emotions and sickness seem to be rising high in this game. Of course, there is no way for me to tell, what is staged and what isn't. Though I'm giving the benefit of the doubt on sickness.
Maybe you are correct and this game is cursed after all?
You do realize, you are still gonna be exxpected to participate after being voted out? So, no reprieve then either.
Sorry I underlined when I should have bolded.

Vote Cat

Also welcome Flockeschnee. Not sure if this is your first game here or if we just haven't crossed paths before, but hope you enjoy yourself before the reformers eat us alive(at least the rate this games going)