Posted October 05, 2009
anjohl: No, it really is a bad film. Terrible pacing, complete reliance on CGI, and absolutely atrocious acting all around.
I've watched it a few times.
Perhaps the pacing when considering the film as a whole is less than stellar, but the pacing within many scenes is extremely impressive. The joker's first encounter with the crime lords is paced well, as is his encounter with Bruce's fundraiser. I would say that the action is paced properly as well - a rather slow, step by step feeling behind each action or punch, but I thought it fit the atmosphere of the movie perfectly. Also, I was actually impressed at the things which were done without CGI - some of the models and of course, the flipping truck, were very nice to see without the CGI feel dragging things down. Dent's face was pretty damn iffy at times, unfortunately, but it could have been worse.
The film's main problem is, as many have said, Bale's goddamn "voice" during Batman scenes - that alone is nearly enough to make me hate The Dark Knight. Oh, how I hate that voice. But I thought that Ledger was fine, Oldman was fine, Eckhart was fine most of the time, and really Bale does okay during his Bruce scenes... Gyllenhaal I'm not a fan of, but I had to hand it to her during the scene in which Dent kisses Rachel before he hops in the truck that leads to the joker's capture. After the kiss has happened, she closes her eyes and makes this face... it's a little silly, but I thought she sold it well. The side characters are all laughably awful, for the most part, which does detract from the overall experience.
anjohl: Wait, you call the sex scene on the stairway "added sex"? Wow. I really have no way to respond to that, since your lack of appreciation for that scene pretty much nullifies any potential conversation we could have.
I thought it was shocking and out of place considering the rest of the film, and I thought it was lacking in taste when considering the source material. I'd love it if you would explain why you appreciate it.
anjohl: About Spiderman 2, it had potential, but having Spidey go around pretty much ripping his mask off every ten minutes pretty much killed it for me.
That's a problem, but the movie did a lot of things right as well.