Posted August 12, 2015
Breja: You are wrong. I honestly believe it's a bad movie. [snip] I often appear contrarian, as my opinion is often a minority report, but I am not contrarian. [snip] You're free to love GotG, or any other movie for that matter, but do not confuse popularity with proof of quality.
For any piece of art to positively touch that many people, there has to be some inherent quality. "Fifty million Elvis fans can't be wrong!" Alas, you seem to be tuned to a different frequency than most. That is a shame as it is never fun to have an opinion that opposes the majority's, but to say the movie doesn't have any merits is just untrue. This is an unknown property (even to some comic book fans) that features a talking raccoon and a talking tree hanging out with a bunch of green-, blue- and pink-skinned aliens. There is nothing about this movie that should have worked. We should be talking about it like we're talking about Fant4stic. Yet, in spite of the odds, most people think the movie is amazing. This is not a "so bad it's good" movie that hipsters say they like ironically. People cried for a tree that only said three words. Others saw it as the Star Wars movie that George Lucas failed to give them in the prequels. It connected with people. With that said, I will say no more. I'm clearly not going to convince you that this movie is good just as you aren't going to convince me of the opposite.
Breja: There is an abundance of popular and yet dismal movies (and other things). Look no further than Twilight for fan artwork, costumes, merchandise, book sales rising etc. An extreme example, (Guardians are not nearly as awful), but relevant.
I detest the Twilight series. It serves no purpose other than being a supernatural soap opera starring cardboard cut-out characters revolving around a main character who might be the most offensive caricature of a woman to date. That said, there is undeniably a small country's worth of people who adore it. I'm not going to get in their way nor am I going to belittle them for liking something that I find repugnant. Popularity certainly doesn't imply quality, but it also doesn't imply inferiority. Each instance is unique.