It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionDisappearing thread(38 posts)(38 posts)
(38 posts)
Pages:
1
2
3
This is my favourite topic
Posted May 23, 2018
avatar
HunchBluntley: Just to be clear, I wasn't talking about the "My posts" page; that one only tracks threads you've posted in for the first time ever, and only for about a week. If you post in a topic that you previously posted in two weeks (or a month, or a year) ago, it won't show up there anyway. This is seemingly the intended behavior.
The bug I'm talking about affects the "Topics I've participated in" section on the right side of this page.
avatar
SirPrimalform: Huh, weird. There definitely were threads new to me just before it got messed up so I can only assume it was affected by the thread deletion in a similar way.
That could be. I've never noticed other threads vanishing prematurely off from "My posts" -- but then, I usually don't bother looking at that page except to see what threads have replies (and stopped doing even that while the notifications system included the forums). I always expect stuff to vanish from that page, so I don't necessarily pay much attention to when it does.
Posted May 24, 2018
Couple years ago a thread was being constantly removed. The user made a script to auto-recreate the thread with the original OP each time (to bring attention to it, not to spam it), and it was up to something like the 50th iteration... It was named something like 'my thread that always gets deleted' or something.


Hmmm....
Posted July 02, 2018
It seems to have happened again... I have a notification for a reply in a thread that no longer exists.
Posted July 02, 2018
There is at least one other thread (about Galaxy being forced on users ... yeah, I know, there are still enough threads about that), that „disappeared“ yesterday after I posted something in it and my best buddy and bff „tinye“ replied to it.
I just assume that it got deleted by a moderator, which would sum up my picture of him (or her) for being not so good with critical comments.
Posted July 02, 2018
low rated
deleted
Post edited July 02, 2018 by Fairfox
Posted July 02, 2018
avatar
john_hatcher: There is at least one other thread (about Galaxy being forced on users ... yeah, I know, there are still enough threads about that), that „disappeared“ yesterday after I posted something in it and my best buddy and bff „tinye“ replied to it.
I just assume that it got deleted by a moderator, which would sum up my picture of him (or her) for being not so good with critical comments.
The thread went off topic and people began to flame each other. As with every thread in which this happens, it was locked for an hour and then deleted.
Post edited July 02, 2018 by Linko90
Posted July 02, 2018
low rated
deleted
Posted July 02, 2018
high rated
avatar
Linko90: The thread went off topic and people began to flame each other. As with every thread in which this happens, it was locked for an hour and then deleted.
I think locking is fine, but deleting is kinda shit for various reasons. For instance googling certain usernames (with "site:gog.com linko90") should also turn up the troll threads and posts so I can check and see if you're worth answering too or if I'm wasting my time and probably will get yelled at ;-)
Posted July 02, 2018
avatar
Linko90: The thread went off topic and people began to flame each other. As with every thread in which this happens, it was locked for an hour and then deleted.
avatar
toxicTom: I think locking is fine, but deleting is kinda shit for various reasons. For instance googling certain usernames (with "site:gog.com linko90") should also turn up the troll threads and posts so I can check and see if you're worth answering too or if I'm wasting my time and probably will get yelled at ;-)
Leaving threads that display the worst of what people can offer is hardly a step in the right direction, even more so when it's littered with people abusing each other.
Posted July 02, 2018
avatar
john_hatcher: There is at least one other thread (about Galaxy being forced on users ... yeah, I know, there are still enough threads about that), that „disappeared“ yesterday after I posted something in it and my best buddy and bff „tinye“ replied to it.
I just assume that it got deleted by a moderator, which would sum up my picture of him (or her) for being not so good with critical comments.
avatar
Linko90: The thread went off topic and people began to flame each other. As with every thread in which this happens, it was locked for an hour and then deleted.
I got some remarks towards this.

a) Why do you delete these threads? Locking, as toxicTom says, is more than enough, if there are no illegal things in it. What about ... if you delete all threads regarding "galaxy is not optional", you can always answer the next upcoming thread with "you are alone, no one ever had a problem with that". Hope I could make my point clear.
b) If this specific thread was "flaming each other", I'll most probably point you to some other threads in the near future.

EDIT regarding a) If you just lock them, you can always add a reason why this is locked and show that you moderate the forums.
Post edited July 02, 2018 by john_hatcher
Posted July 02, 2018
avatar
Linko90: The thread went off topic and people began to flame each other. As with every thread in which this happens, it was locked for an hour and then deleted.
avatar
john_hatcher: I got some remarks towards this.

a) Why do you delete these threads? Locking, as toxicTom says, is more than enough, if there are no illegal things in it. What about ... if you delete all threads regarding "galaxy is not optional", you can always answer the next upcoming thread with "you are alone, no one ever had a problem with that". Hope I could make my point clear.
b) If this specific thread was "flaming each other", I'll most probably point you to some other threads in the near future.
Not all the GOG Galaxy threads have been deleted, there are 2 in the first few pages alone.

As for your second point, feel free to. As other users have, and I have followed this up with moderation. This is not a new process, I have done this since I started here. If users can't restrain themselves from going off topic or turning a post into an insult sword fight, and the thread does not provide any long-term service, the thread will be locked and deleted. The users who took part in said insults will also be contacted and met with moderation.



Edit - It's quite clear I moderate the forums.
Post edited July 03, 2018 by Linko90
Posted July 03, 2018
avatar
toxicTom: I think locking is fine, but deleting is kinda shit for various reasons. For instance googling certain usernames (with "site:gog.com linko90") should also turn up the troll threads and posts so I can check and see if you're worth answering too or if I'm wasting my time and probably will get yelled at ;-)
avatar
Linko90: Leaving threads that display the worst of what people can offer is hardly a step in the right direction, even more so when it's littered with people abusing each other.
Can't you just delete the offending posts? I mean, what if a thread is full of valuble inforomation, or answers someone's problem, and then a troll or two appear and bam! the whole thread is gone? Hardly sounds right. Sounds like an easy way for the trolls to cause even greater havoc.

Also, I honestly have no idea what that "worst of what people can offer" in that thread about Galaxy was. I agree some people responded to the OP in a unwarranted, hostile way, but nothing so bad as to make the thread deserve deletion.
Posted July 03, 2018
avatar
Linko90: Leaving threads that display the worst of what people can offer is hardly a step in the right direction, even more so when it's littered with people abusing each other.
Just a thought, I think you probably have the power to edit/delete single posts, right? If there's something really nasty maybe that's an alternative to deleting the entire thread? Certainly that's how I've seen plenty of moderation done on other forums, a previously nasty post be replaced by a mod note to remain civil.
Posted July 03, 2018
avatar
Linko90: Leaving threads that display the worst of what people can offer is hardly a step in the right direction, even more so when it's littered with people abusing each other.
avatar
Breja: Can't you just delete the offending posts? I mean, what if a thread is full of valuble inforomation, or answers someone's problem, and then a troll or two appear and bam! the whole thread is gone? Hardly sounds right. Sounds like an easy way for the trolls to cause even greater havoc.

Also, I honestly have no idea what that "worst of what people can offer" in that thread about Galaxy was. I agree some people responded to the OP in a unwarranted, hostile way, but nothing so bad as to make the thread deserve deletion.
Please see my comment as it clearly underlines posts with lasting service will not be deleted. As for the post in question, it was the 3rd of it's type on the page. And yet again, we had the same arguing about 'DRM/Steam' etc, but only this time people began to get much more firey with their replies. Hence the lock/deleting of the topic.


As for 'just deleting the troll replies' the fact is, most aren't trolls. They're regular users who for some reason have bouts of uncivil arguing. Deleting posts non-stop does little to halt the behavior.
Posted July 03, 2018
avatar
Breja: Also, I honestly have no idea what that "worst of what people can offer" in that thread about Galaxy was. I agree some people responded to the OP in a unwarranted, hostile way, but nothing so bad as to make the thread deserve deletion.
The worst response that I read in that thread was made by the person you quoted. ;-)
Pages:
1
2
3
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionDisappearing thread(38 posts)(38 posts)
(38 posts)