Fonzer: So what is good about Diablo 2?
I could never get into it even though i have it on cd and the expansion cd which i found in a store long ago. Played it a little and i always though allies in the game made me stop playing kinda when i got them, played until i found the smithy of the first game and stopped
Kinda liked diablo 1 with it's atmosphere, but Diablo 2 i don't know why i don't like it.
I never really got into it either. Iike you said, I love the first game for its atmosphere, it's one of those laser-focused games that deliver an incredibly tight, immersive experience followed by a sequel that just feels too big and all over the place. Batman Arkham Asylum and Arkham City were a lot like that too (though at least I finished City, unlike Diablo 2).
That doesn't mean I think Diablo 2 is a bad game, but it jsut feels more like... a game. I know that sounds stupid, but when playing Diablo 1 I really feel like I'm on this lonely quest descending deeper and deeper into a dark labyrinth. When playing Diablo 2, especially after Act 1, I just feel like I'm clicking monsters to death.