ElTerprise: I gave up twice on 1Q84...i actually don't no why...
Did you read it in German or English (or Japanese...)?
I... can't read Murakami in German. I of course would love to read him in Japanese, but (obvious reason here).
And even though the books are now translated from Japanese to German directly (and not from English, like in the past) I still have the strong feeling that the English translations are magnitudes better, more sensitive, more rich, less vulgar regarding sex (which is a recurring theme).
For 1Q84: Well it's a really slow book. Sometimes painfully slow. And with a lot of repetition (but told with slightly different nuances). I guess it's a love or hate thing. I liked it, although I stalled on my second read. My favourite is still "Kafka on the Shore" (read 4 times) with a close second of "Dance Dance Dance" (read 3 times).