Stilton: I agree that the flavour of the month club dominates too much when putting the cast of a film together. Marketing can really screw up the natural development of art. In publishing, genre titles (fantasy, sci-fi, horror, romance, crime) are heavily influenced by word count because a book of 'X' thousand words sells £8.99 or whatever, which to me is ludicrous. If a genre title comes in at too much under its less likely to be taken on. A trilogy or series is big too because you then have a captive market who will hopefully keep spending to complete the series. I suppose its a case of everyone mutually scratching backs, but coming from the creative side of things I'd prefer a little more respect for ideas and where they come from.
adaliabooks: Yeah, publishers are looking to fill a formula of whatever's popular at that moment; whether that's gory and violent, full of sex scenes, aimed at teenagers or whatever else. And it has to fit within a certain length, too short or too long and they don't want it.
I do like a good trilogy, and I find when I plan a story it tends to naturally gravitate towards that format (but that's probably because it's what I'm used to reading) but I know what you mean, sometimes you wonder what people might write if they weren't thinking it's got to be a trilogy so it will get published / sell well. Sometimes you feel a book would have worked better as a standalone novel rather than being dragged out into three just for the sake of it, or that it might be better with more detail and time and spread over more books.
We have Lord of the Rings to blame for that I think... :)
Lord of the Rings I feel is an exception, and your smile indicates you might feel the same way. Its simply a separate beast from everything else, even from the books and films it inspired and still inspires. It doesn't rest on hallowed ground, it
is hallowed ground.
I can't recall how many times I've read a book and thought, 'Jeez, when is this thing going to end?' The waffle I've had to wade through because of 'unit size' could fill a small library, and worse than that, it encourages the great windbags of our age to keep right on blowing. I don't think Stephen King has written anything in the last six or eight decades that couldn't have been circumcised with a very large knife and not been any different. When I see his latest title in a bookshop with a sticker that says £5 OFF I always wonder if they're referring to its physical weight. Fortunately I gave up on him a long time ago, but the thought still wryly crosses my mind.