-Mithridates-: Some people seem to believe that false accusations against men very rarely happens but I seriously doubt that.
I can see both sides of this and have a short story that terrifies me. I've actually probably known more women who have been raped (sometimes violently or underage) as I ended up in one of those child boot camp type places when I was a teen. So I know it is a real and terrible thing, but on to my story which is also terrible.
One of my best friends had sex with a girl our circle of friends knew. There was no romantic relationship AT ALL but they would hook-up on occasion when they were in town during our college years. Not here to shame women but the girl was extremely open with the fact that she was DTF with whoever and never tried to hide who she slept with. Anyways it was a Saturday night or whatever and like 6 or 7 people were crashing at an apartment. We all went to bed and they did it on the couch in the living room. My other friend actually walked in on them with her riding as he went to the kitchen. Obviously he sort of looked the other way and went back to his bedroom. I was asleep 2 rooms away and heard nothing.
So the next morning I'm driving my friend home and he mentions he hooked up with the girl. This was not news and I was sort of annoyed thinking he was being immature and bragging. Then he says "it was really weird. After it was over she got up, hit the restroom, got dressed, walked right past me, and left without even saying goodbye or anything". I agreed it was weird but given her attitude towards sex it would have been much stranger from anyone else. He went back to his college a few hours away. Three days later the police show up to search the apartment this all happened at and check the bathroom. I called him and did the whole "I don't know what happened but you might want to know or make some lawyer calls". He was stunned but said thanks.
Two weeks later the police pull him out of his college lecture and stick him in the back of a car in cuffs for a 4 hour ride to the city I live in. He was stuck in county another two weeks before he made bail and has terrifying stories. He got a brand new orange jumpsuit just before his court hearing because he had blood on him from being next to a fight that broke out in holding over snacks. Myself and the other friend had to go give statements to the Sex Crimes Unit Detectives.
Our circle of friends evaporated and turned on us claiming we were defending a rapist. We tried to explain that as we were at the scene they said we had to answer questions and weren't giving any form of character testimony. For instance , "I went to sleep around 2:45am in the last bedroom on the right".
I know this long but here comes the twist. The girls from our larger group of friends were having like dinner dates trying to think up any possible off-hand comment or "creep" behavior they could use against him. They invited his ex-gf to these as they had not split amicably. She was a good person (just not a good match) and when they started trying to ask her for dirt and coach her on how to embellish anything bad she might have to say, she noped out. She came to me and our other friend and was like I wasn't there so I have no idea what happened but they're trying to ruin his life (minimum 25 year sentence there) and no matter how much I dislike him it's wrong. Apparently the girl accusing him was angry with him over something minor from the last time they saw each other and hooked up. He made an asshole comment or something verbal like that.
I went from having a group of like 15 or 20 friends that would all get together to 2 and I didn't even do or see anything. The charges got dropped over lack of any evidence, but his life was changed of course. Switched colleges. Legal fees. His parents obviously seeing a very private side of his life nobody wants to share. Started drinking, like a lot.
I wasn't in the room so I'll never know for certain but I'm leaning towards it wasn't rape. She didn't have any legal repercussions and seems to have continued on as before. Rape is a terrible thing and I'm never even in the "she was asking for it" camp. It's wrong. It's horrible. I do think we need to talk about fake rape claims though because they can ruin a life too. There isn't always good evidence for rape and I understand why but if there is evidence that lies are being told shouldn't we have some accountability for that?