I'm usually all over these mystery game sales but looking at the list there are maybe 3 or 4 I am interested in (Anna's Quest, Gabriel Knight, etc) , several I don't know about but may potentially like, and several I own on steam or ps3 (saints row, spelunky, rogue legacy). Just doesn't seem like it is worth the risk this time around with all of the potential duplicates, I wish these mystery drawings focused more on Good Old Games found mostly only on gog.

...and I just tried again and got apotheon...

something this time that I had actually thought about purchasing several times...

my mystery mystery game finally revealed itself to be breach and clear

...and well I took a third toss now,and it was meh:
Raiden III

bleh arcade game...

So this is weird.

This Morning I bought one and got

A Golden Wake

Then I bought a second and got the "Mystery Game Bug"

It started showing whether that game was a gift or not so I came back later and when it didn't say it was a gift I got one and got

Airline Tycoon Deluxe

When I checked my account for Airline Tycoon I had

Breach and Clear

added from the earlier mystery game and I decided to check my orders history to see how breach and clear was taken care of and it said I had an additional pending Mystery Game Order that hadn't been paid for yet and bought completed it and got(the bug was "fixed" by giving me the un-owned game Breach and Clear and a new mystery game order that hadn't been purchased - at least I don't remember having a game in my cart)

Gabriel Knight 20th Anniversary

I then bought mystery games and got

Supreme League of Patriots
Anna's Quest
Elminage Gothic
Aquaria
Agarest: Generations of War
Cities in Motion
Shantae: Risky's Revenge - Directors Cut
Europa Universalis III Complete
Breach and Clear - Deadline
Train Fever

So all in all I paid for 14 and got 14, while I got games I didn't care about I got plenty I did.

And it's currently telling me there are still games I don't have but I don't know yet what they are(it's not saying this order is a gift).

First time I ever got a mystery game and it is:

Aquaria

Never heard of it before, but it looks interesting. Several reviews say it's a bit like Ecco, which I loved. Overall, very pleased. I think I'll keep it.

Didn't think of the rule that it doesn't prioritize the games that you don't own when you buy something as a gift. Got Crimsonland and The Bard's Tale (which I both already own).

Will use them as additional prizes in my Christmas Avatar giveaway.

Rolled the dice and got:

Lilly Looking Through

and

Rogue Legacy

Probably will sit on the shelf but it was worth a try.

After hours of waiting my mystery game was redeemed and I got Battle Realms + Winter of the Wolf. I never heard of it before, but it looks pretty nice and seems to have some glowing reviews from the community. I am okay with this :)

Now I just need to decide whether or not I want to gamble away another couple of bucks to try for Shantae: Risky's Revenge and Spelunky.

It said so only because of the Mystery Game bug, which one temporarily had in one's orders.

It's a great, great game. You'll need around 8 hours to finish it and it's tremendous adventure. Enjoy.

I got

INQUISITOR
HEARTS OF IRON II COMPLETE

I guess it's fine because I don't have these two neither her nor on Steam. However, I don't think I'll have any patience, will nor time to enjoy these. And the rest of the list is 80% have, 15% wouldn't want anyway, 5% would like to try at some point so no more gambling.

P.S. Hearts of Iron II was first 'mystery gift'. I've sent mail to support and it got resolved in a few hours. Try it.

Thanks for the list!

Just one game I'd be really interested in so I guess I'll skip the whole mystery thing.

Is there a recognized time limit on having GOG Support convert Mystery game purchases into gifts? I would like to do it in the next couple of days if possible rather than spending a bunch of time today.

OMG so addictive.
I made out like a bandit last Pinata, and it seems the Pinata gods are still madly in love with me.

"WoHoo!"
- Anna's Quest
- Aquaria
- Breach and Clear
- Breach and Clear: Deadline
- Gabriel Knight 20th Anniversary
- Saint's Row 2
- Saint's Row 3rd
- Shantae: Risky's Revenge
- Supreme League of Patriots

"ooh"
- Airline Tycoon Deluxe
- Europa Universalis III (not) Complete
- Train Fever

"Meh"
- Raiden III

and perhaps most importantly, no repeats