Posted October 14, 2020
kmanitou: I've seen a lot of reports of niggles and problems with Ryzen over the years, so I'm sure it's a real issue for some people. I wonder if AMD thought about that before raising their prices and making Intel look more competitive again.
clarry: I'm using a first gen Ryzen (1800X, pre-ordered). It has the segfault bug that was widely publicized during the time and corrected for later batches of the same CPU. Apart from that, as long as you choose RAM that it is compatible with (and don't go crazy with overclocking), it's rock solid. I can't trace a single bug or crash to "cpu is broken", other than RAM related random failures and the segfault issue Linux & BSD users found when compiling stuff. (Also using AMD EPYC as a workhorse at work and it's rock solid) So I'd be extremely sceptical of anyone who blames their game crashes on AMD CPUs. I think we'd be hearing more about it in tech news outlets if it were a real issue with AMD CPUs.
I'm surprised about "just could not perform" claim since even the second gen Zen chips were very close to Intel in terms of single-thread IPC. I have the vibe that we're not getting the whole story here.
A motherboard maker can make the CPU throw errors or bluescreens due improper voltage control or "defective" supply. As stated RAM stability is somewhat motherboard related as well.
To makes stuff worse, good motherboard reviews are pretty much non-existent to my knowledge (not surprising, given the absurd quantity of parts on the market). And I do not mean those "reviews" that just count the number of "VRM phases" and moar better!
Intel seems to be much more closed regarding the platform implementation but not necessarily a bad thing. Can only guess the experience dealing with HP, Dell and Lenovo's accounts a little...
While I use the 1600AF, wich is pretty much a 2600, it doesn't win any FPS race for sure, in some games it struggle to achieve 144fps all the times but the only errors I've seen are caused by my own over/underclocks. From playing games to simulation work always rock solid.
A improper setup on a 10600K can cause errors as well.
One big advntage Intel has over AMD, regarding to playing games is emulation.Some emulators are built around Intel instruction set only, like RPCS3 and Intel TSX.
Post edited October 14, 2020 by Dark_art_