tfishell: You might get more unbiased opinions on the r/gog subreddit
I guess r/gog readers are "biased" too because the last time I read it,
people were generally negative towards it there too...
Nope. That's not an honest appraisal of the situation at all. You're trying too hard to put words into people's mouths then argue against your own projections (Big hint:
people who start threads like this are not blind Epic haters)... Re-read
post #8 which is a summary of the actual main two points people were discussing on the old thread:-
1. GOG may try very hard to want everyone to believe "it's all about branding", but the real issue with
"the Epic version is good enough to be sold on GOG" is the very obvious economics for game developers for launching on Epic first (exclusive or not) and then *not* re-releasing DRM-Free on GOG when
"our Epic version can be our GOG Galaxy version" is painfully obvious, AND they get paid a larger cut from selling Epic versions on Galaxy than selling a proper GOG version on GOG. What GOG want (branding) and want game publishers want (more money, reduced distribution costs like only needing one version for two stores) are not remotely aligned at all on this. You're hoping they'll like what you like but in reality they will make more money doing the opposite.
2. The "meta-launcher" gamble is unbelievably fragile. GOG's API is under GOG's control, but the ability to continue to "scrape" data from Steam is absolutely under Steam's control. They could at any time, hard break it (start rejecting connections if they come from non-Steam clients) or simply soft degrade it (eg, slow down the rate at which Steam game library gets populated in Galaxy 100x, so loading +800 games into Steam takes 15s, importing the same 800 games into Galaxy ends up 25mins or random "connection errors" 50% of the time, who's going to use that as a launcher then?). It's so ridiculous that
people are fantasising about seizing a quarter of Steam's business via permanent long-term unrestricted data scraping of the competition's servers, without thinking about the obvious likely response here...