It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I was finally able to do it. I don't know why OpenShot would always croak at 74% (either preview, or exporting to a mp4 video) when using a particular mp3 file, but when I used a captured wav version of that same file, it worked fine. E.g. VLC plays the mp3 file fine. Does OpenShot have problems with mp3 files in general, or was that some freak occurence?

Other than that, I liked OpenShot, it was quite easy to use for a beginner, something that definitely can't be said for lots of other "Movie Maker alternatives" that I tried.

avatar
PixelBoy: You can, for instance, use PowerPoint or its free alternatives to create a presentation that features both audio and pictures and even some easy animations.

Put that in fullscreen mode, and use some screen recording software to capture that, and there you have your video.
Yeah I read somewhere that the presentation tool in e.g. Open Office actually has the option to export the presentation to a video file. I was hoping Libre Office 5's presentation tool would have the same capability, but apparently it didn't. I was able to make such a simple presentation with it, but not export it to a video file.

I was hoping not having to use video capturing to achieve this, it just somehow feels "wrong" for making such a simple presentation.

avatar
amrit9037: Seriously?
You want a software for THAT?
Yeah I figured it is such a simple task that any simple software should be able to do it... but when I googled for something like "music video youtube still picture", most instructions suggested using the (discontinued) Windows Movie Maker, or even some oddball net services which want to know your Youtube username and password (ummm, right, as if I am going to give those to some 3rd party web site).

For some reason I didn't find anywhere a suggestion to use VLC, Some site listed VLMC (which is from the same people, a free video editor), but as far as I could tell it is not even released yet, even for beta testing.
Post edited March 09, 2017 by timppu
avatar
timppu: I installed and tried OpenShot (2.2.0) yesterday, and so far it is maybe the best option I've tried. It feels quite intuitive and easy to use, I just added two tracks in the timeline, a PNG picture to one and a mp3 file on the other, then extended the photo track to be the same length as the mp3 music, and maybe a simply fade in/fade out effect to the start and the end of the picture.

But it has some stability problems. If I preview that simple presentation, towards the end of it the music it becomes garbled, and the program doesn't do anything anymore. I have to exit the program, at which point Windows complains it has become unresponsive etc.

If I try to export that project to a MP4 video file (without previewing it), it proceeds until 74%, but then stops there and doesn't do anything anymore. So I don't know if there is e.g. some problem with the mp3 file, but at least it plays just fine in VLC player, from start to end.

I also tried Shotcut, but I had hard time understanding how to do what I wanted (just that simple "add a picture, and an audio file to play in the background"), plus it seemed VERY unstable. The program kept crashing here and there, e.g. if I made the timeline visible, added a track, and then merely right-clicked on that track... poof, the program crashed. It happened quite often when pressing different buttons etc. which didn't have a description what they even do. OBS Studio? I have it installed already, but I couldn't figure out how to do what I want (ie. just add a picture and an audio file). Not sure if this is more like a live video capture program (and editor?), rather than a "movie maker"?
OBS isn't a video editor, but it can sort of be used in a way to do some kinds of things that are sort of live-edits by triggering scene changes and whatnot. It is primarily a live streaming program with the ability to record, but you can just record with it also. Not what most people would want/need for editing specifically but a cool program worth poking around with nonetheless in the video realm.
avatar
timppu:
ffmpeg is much easier

ffmpeg -loop 1 -r 1 -i image.jpg -i audio.mp3 -shortest -acodec copy video.mp4
avatar
amrit9037: ffmpeg is much easier

ffmpeg -loop 1 -r 1 -i image.jpg -i audio.mp3 -shortest -acodec copy video.mp4
Unfortunately it didn't work, it gave an error:

'ffmpeg' is not recognized as an internal or external command,
operable program or batch file.

What do you mean I should first download ffmpeg? I thought this was supposed to be done without (additional) software? :)
avatar
amrit9037: ffmpeg is much easier

ffmpeg -loop 1 -r 1 -i image.jpg -i audio.mp3 -shortest -acodec copy video.mp4
avatar
timppu: Unfortunately it didn't work, it gave an error:

'ffmpeg' is not recognized as an internal or external command,
operable program or batch file.

What do you mean I should first download ffmpeg? I thought this was supposed to be done without (additional) software? :)
Oops... Yes you need ffmpeg for it.

Get this(13mb): https://ffmpeg.zeranoe.com/builds/win32/static/ffmpeg-20160316-git-d0a9114-win32-static.7z

Extract in a folder.
Put your image.jpg (image file) and audio.mp3 (audio file) in bin folder.

Click on ff-prompt.bat
Run that command.


ffmpeg -loop 1 -r 1 -i image.jpg -i audio.mp3 -shortest -acodec copy video.mp4


And you will find video.mp4 (video output) in bin folder.
avatar
amrit9037: And you will find video.mp4 (video output) in bin folder.
I'll have to remember ffmpeg for the future. Albeit, I kinda liked how I could make those fade-in/fade-out effects so easily with e.g. OpenShot. It gave me that warm and fuzzy stevenspielbergish feeling. You know, as if you are a real movie director and shit.
Post edited March 09, 2017 by timppu
Blender is good.
low rated
Windows Movie Maker has been removed. If you are now looking for similar software, I think AceMovi is a good choice. Basically all the necessary functions, and there are a lot of online content
avatar
timppu: I need to make a simple "video" to youtube, just music with one still picture. I've googled for how to do it, and most suggest using Windows Movie Maker.
For very small projects I still use Movie Maker. It's included in the Windows 2012 Essentials suite. It works with Windows 10 and there is no need for a license or key.
Post edited July 08, 2021 by Mori_Yuki