Time to be the asshole again. (spoilers for Arrival follow)
I wasn't originally going to do this. I've seen Arrival on Saturday, and I wasn't impressed with it much, but I wasn't quite feeling like talking shit about it here. Maybe after spending the last couple of days sick just left me in a mood to bitch about something, but really I just think I've had enough of the crazy level of praise this movie is getting.
Here's the thing- Arrival is not a bad movie. It's not. It's pretty well made, the acting is mostly decent and Amy Adams is really good. Not dazzling, but good. The visuals are fine. But we don't really get anything new here, the characters are not very interesting (to say the least), and the whole thing is rather predictable and could easily be at least 15-20 minutes shorter. It's an ok movie, but nothing more. But everyone seems to be going crazy over it, from left and right I'm hearing how it's the best movie of the year, a new sci-fi classic to go down in history... calm the fuck down.
This movie really doesn't do anything we haven't seen before in the genre. The Shymalan style twist is impossible not to spot from a mile away. The idea of experiencing time as non-linear has been done before, on TV, in comics and in movies. The "Doctor Manhatta reminiscing" part of Watchmen did it perfectly, both the comic and the movie, in a haunting way much more powerful than this movie's weak twist. And if you want a twist based on that idea, look no further than the finale of Star Trek the Next Generation. And that's just two things that first came to my mind while still in cinema.
It feels to me like this is a sci-fi masterpiece for people who don't really know much sci-fi. It doesn't even tell it's story in a particularly daring way, it's actually pretty by the numbers, it's not visually impressive enough to warrant needing to be seen on the big screen, and doesn't need to be as long as it is.