So,according to the walkthrough here when I talked to Penthalos in the Dwarven Halls, I should've gotten an option to get the cure for the animals in Bartolos House. Well, no such dialogue choices comes up, even though I have in fact been to and received the "animals" quest.

According to this walkthrough, I should've received a quest to retrieve some holy water he will need to mix the cure. No such dialogue choices come up.

So, do I need to ask?? Is it a bug?

ADDED IN EDIT: Anyone having an issue with paragraph breaks when you edit?? I swear it seems like everytime I edit a post, when I click "Post my message" it all shows up as one paragraph and I have to edit it again to put the paragraph breaks back in.
Oh, FWIW, I have not only been to the house, but I have in fact killed the mage, (and a snake there too) and when I left I had promised a cow I would find the cure. Don't know if that matters or not, just letting anyone know.

Thanks, that did it.

For whatever reason, this ( of all the nutty quests LOL) was the one quest I sort of recalled from my playthrough 10 or so years ago. And I remembered the priest in Halls having something to do with it, went there after killing Boratus, and.. nothing.

So then found this walkthrough hoping it would help, but I didn't see anything about opening a chest and reading book. lol totaly forgot that from last time.

Thanks again.

I've done that a couple times, half remembering quests or sections of games and getting ahead of where my character should be.