wayke: Part of QA is also management agreeing on what the finished product is acceptable as,
frogthroat: I don't exactly agree, but I do understand what you mean. Yes, the managerial side is a part of the process, but not a part of the QA department.
From how I understand it, the devs and the QA did their best and it is the management and marketing that have the full blame on this one. Management pushed an unfinished product out, in spite of devs' and QA's warnings and marketing promised way more than the game could deliver.
My finger is pointing directly at the management.
Did you read about the vulnerability? Some modder (PixelRick) found a security risk. A few days later CDPR, instead of releasing a hotfix, wrote a message "modders bad". (
https://twitter.com/CDPRED_Support/status/1356604047671898112 ) So another modder (yamasushi, known for Cyber Engine Tweaks) had to make a modder side statement (
https://forums.cdprojektred.com/index.php?threads/important-pc-version-vulnerability.11078852/#post-12855656 ). The management and marketing just keep on messing up. Instead of releasing a critical hotfix to address a security vulnerability, they threw modders under the bus. I don't understand why the stock holders don't demand that CDPR replaces the whole upper management.
Yeah, just read this, very disappointing. CRM 101 was clearly not provided as training to those in charge.