Arachnarok_Rider: I owe you a response in that other topic, where I feel your comments were actually very reasonable, all things considered. I don't quite agree with them, needless to say, but they're reasonable all the same. However, work and real life...
But in this topic, you're really just pushing misinformation and nonsensical speculation. Not reasonable at all.
Like I said initially, Andromeda was not brought down because all the developers were incompetent. I don't know whether they were or not, mind you, but it really doesn't matter, because the much bigger issue lies in how that project was managed. That being said, if everybody on that team had in fact been incompetent then surely there wouldn't have been a decent enough but buggy game at the end despite the development process.
But you're pretending that it was down to *every single dev* who all individually failed to do their job, even though their job was to do what their bosses told them to do. You're further seemingly pretending that random devs just do whatever they want, whenever they want, just because. And that just does not make any sense.
FYI, grunt level developers don't make the calls, they just execute them. It's not their job to make the big calls. Some times they'll poke their boss on the shoulder and suggest that maybe this isn't how it should be, but you can't run a big production if everybody just goes around and do whatever they want, and people who do those kinds of things anyway will inevitably get found out and kicked out.
As for the "illegitimate censorship", you're commenting on their forum, instigating negativity against their employees. What did you expect? No, you do not have any right whatsoever to comment what you like, and no, it really isn't legitimate to try and hound former Bioware employees, blaming them individually for an EA affiliate having collectively made a disappointing game, in no small part due to said affiliate being forced to switch engine during development.
Please take your time responding in the other topic, I relate to how busy life can get, and I would much rather you construct a response that you are happy with than a quick reply, because I genuinely appreciate the fact that we can discuss different views frankly without devolving into a fight.
It therefore saddens me slightly that you feel I am being unreasonable here. I am not saying that every single dev individually failed their job. And believe me, I am well aware that grunts don't get to call big shots. But it is not true that developers don't just go around and do whatever they want: maybe not while working on the game, but they certainly do on social media.
This brings me to the difference we seem to have in view as to why Bioware is going down the drain. I don't think the chief cause is technical ineptitude, but a policy of pushing a SJW agenda.
Why else did it take them so long to reluctantly let racist genocidal maniac Manveer Heir go? Why else is gamer gate feminazi and proponent of false rape allegations Sam Maggs still working at Bioware? Why did we go from having one lesbian in Knights of the Old Republic I, and one bisexual in Jade Empire and Mass Effect 1, to having entire cauldrons of alphabet soup in Inquisition, Andromeda and Anthem?
Bioware has a long history of promoting extreme leftist ideology, but they are becoming more and more open and bold about it. And they are becoming more and more radical, as they replace good people with common sense, by politically correct noise-making machines who publicly admit they despise the gaming community.
This would damage any company and it is clearly destroying Bioware. And to me it seems that we are seeing the same thing happening, at smaller scale or in a earlier phase, at CDPR, what with the firing of Sean 'Linko' Halliday, and the hiring of their current CDPR and steam forum moderators.
Now I agree with you that Bioware is not (yet) completely devoid of any technical skill, otherwise Andromeda would have looked even shoddier, especially more so than the unreleased version where women were actually not hideous. But if their policy of political propaganda is not changed rapidly, they will go bust nonetheless. Maybe our 'hero and saviour' Tim Sweeney can prop-up their failing agitprop.
As for your arguments regarding the steam forum: you are incorrect. The OP of that last thread was clearly at no point instigating negativity of any form; the spineless git was in fact being very eager to make sure everything went according to their stupid guidelines, even though the moderators clearly only uphold these when they feel there is any chance of legitimate criticism of Cyberpunk 2077 coming to light.
The guy literally got banned for telling people to stop speculating and stay on topic, because that now constitutes a witch hunt.
CDPR should know better that to try and silence free speech! When has that ever ended well on the free market? You only get away with that, if you have the power and resources of Soviet Russia, the People's Republic of China or Nazi Germany behind you, and even then it goes South on you eventually.