J Lo: As for how, I suspect he is deliberately withholding information that can save V. I'm pretty confident the information he gives V is correct, but there's this nagging feeling in me that wonders if Hellman knows of some therapy, or can direct V to someone who can increase V's odds. Also keep in mind that there's no consequence to Hellman for letting V die.
That one I fully agree with. Hellman may not be lying, but he has no reason to tell the whole truth either.
And he rather insistently wants V to go back to Arasaka, as they are "the only ones who can help".
Would make sense that Hellman would want that, and be the one who brings in both the relic and the test subject, considering he has likely burned all bridges with Kang Tao due to V's actions in taking care of the AV.
With Takemura's involvement - which I'm sure Kang Tao will get wind of - Kang Tao will likely hold Arasaka responsible for bringing Hellman back.
And suddenly Hellman has 2 corporations after him. Not really helpful for a relaxed retirement, I'm sure. If he comes back to Arasaka, bringing V and the chip with him, I'm sure they can forgive...for a time.
J Lo: I suspect the same thing with Alt. In one of the endings, you can ask Alt if she can work something out that can save both you and Johnny. She says "no", but I wonder if that's not entirely true.
No arguments there. Since Alt was basically Johnny's "dump and re-do" input, and she's a digitized version of the real Alt, I wouldn't be surprised if the AI Alt still held some resentment towards Johnny.
Kinda like a "you didn't care about me before, why should I care about you now"-relationship moment. With V caught in the middle.
J Lo: I apologize if this sounds like some bonkers conspiracy theory. Another apology if my post isn't clear, my tranquilizers are setting in.
No worries - this is a video game, not politics. Video game conspiracy theories are expected. And I find from personal experience the best theories comes when the brain is a bit more...unfiltered (as it tends to be when not fully awake). :)