Aalda11: Anybody tried the Civ IV Colonization addon? How does it compare to the great classic? Is it worth is?
Is it really an add-on? I would call it a remarke, because as far as I remember (and I remember well since I reinstalled it a couple of weeks ago) you don't need the original Civ IV to play Civ IV's Colonization. In fact it's just Colonization redone with Civ IV's engine.
Now for the differences. Let me be clear here: my opinion might not be totally impartial, since I'm a great fan of the original game. Let's just say I think that if you were a fan of the original one, the original one will always be better.
If not, just know that Civ IV's Colonization is all original Colonization is, plus fancy graphics, streamlined UI and very welcome additions, like for example marking the training the natives can provide your troops settlement by settlement (that village can train you in Expert Farmer, that one in Seasoned Scouts, etc.), a thing the original didn't (so you had to remember everything).
But... for me it's just not the same. Freecol is also excellent... but not the same.
I have spent so many hours on the original game (and will spend again so many thanks to GOG!) that any remake of it, good or bad, will always be at least slightly inferior. I understant it's more a matter of nostalgia than anything else. ^_^
But on a more objective note, the original Colonization is still great even by today's standards, it's not just nostalgia speaking (like it is when I say I like Heros of Might and Magic 1)