crysisheld: What is the big difference between the remastered ones and the real old games? I remember that the graphics were not that much of a remaster. Anything else that makes the older games so special? Or what is so good that people insist on getting the original games instead of just the remastered versions?
There's hardly any difference at all for graphics:-
Original : https://i.imgur.com/AM5DZju.jpg Remaster : https://i.imgur.com/ejFnWfi.jpg In fact in the Remaster, Andrew Ryan's statue above seems to have lost his moustache, and to me the damp walls of the lighthouse actually look better on the original. A lot of other scenes look different without actually looking better just to be seen to change something. The main reason they were "remastered" was simply the publishers wanted another console release as a trilogy to bump up the price of old games again (Skyrim & Beamdog style). Unfortunately the games were half-heartedly ported from Unreal Engine 2 to 3 and that introduced a load of bugs that were far worse than what the originals have. Eg, the worst problem I've ever encounter with Bioshock "Classics" was the need to tick "Run this program in compatibility mode for..." and then XP if there was no sound when using certain Realtek chips, and use the 60fps physics patch. But they were user fixable in about 30 seconds.
The Remasters have far worse bugs include constant crashes and save-game corruption in the core engine code which aren't fixable by the user.
Original = Takes 30s longer to install but is otherwise stable.
Remaster = Supposedly more "modern" but for many is one giant crash-fest that really doesn't look "remastered" at all compared to even free amateur texture packs for 20 year old games like Thief or Deus Ex. All this wouldn't be so bad if they were aggressive with fixing up bugs, but even the Steam version has gone over a year virtually abandoned in an appalling buggy state given the high-rating and popularity of the originals.
Edit: Other differences are:-
- Remasters run at around 2/3rds the fps so for older lower-end rigs : 40fps Remaster = 60fps Originals.
- Remasters are 2-3x the install size. Eg, Bioshock 1 = 6.5GB (original) vs 20.7GB (Remaster). Bioshock 2 = 9.5GB (Original minus MP) vs 18.1GB Remaster. Inevitably, startup times are also longer on the Remasters.