Kilkakon: Just bought the game yesterday and ran into this three separate times, locking out the horn in the Dark Lantern Catacombs. Any ideas? Game is literally unplayable if this keeps happening.
If you go through the Underground City to the Elder Tree and then the Reed plains, there is a spell in the center that costs a lot of mana and will destroy boulders and traps.
Then you can go back and destroy the boulder to get the summoning horn.
If you have the seashell, you can go underwater and complete the sunken ship. The stone creature in the lantern guards the entrance to get to the book in the lantern, which will teach you a spell.
If you do the sunken ship before going into the Underground city, you should be strong enough to get through the reed plain to get the spell in the center.