zollac: I think the game is ok (7/10 in my opinion). However there are lots of things that could be improved. I've only finished the predator campaign so far, but here's my opinion anyway:
1. Melee: first, there's no such thing as damage direction indicator, so when an alien sneakily attacks you, there's no way to know immediately where the alien is. Second, moving will push enemies away from you. Sometimes it takes 7~8 tries to make a successful strike. Third, sometimes melee simply doesn't work. I don't know why, but when I and the alien both stand still at close distance, my melee attacks would fail to hit, while the alien killing me. In summery, melee works 70% of the time for me, but the other 30% it's annoying.
2. Elevators: why i must leave an elevator immediately after it reaches a floor, or I'll be sent back to the floor I'm from? Minor but annoying.
3. Hint message: they disappears too fast and will never appear again. If I miss one of them I'll have to go watch a walkthrough video or I wouldn't have any idea how to finish the level.
4. Speargun: There's no way to know how much ammo is left.
5. Only three saves in a level, why? The player is forced to play the game with extreme cautious and this makes the game a lot less fun.
6. Facehugger: wtf???? Yes I'm mad here. This tiny little creature pose more threat than an alien queen. It's fast, hard to hit, and it would insta-kill you? No thanks. No.
I'm not saying the game is bad. but it is not a very good one.
I have to disagree with most of what you say here.
1. I have no idea what you mean by "melee." Only the alien really uses melee attacks. You don't have to be so close that you're touching the enemy for a claw attack or tail swipe to hit. Claws are mediocre, a charged tail attack is an instant kill against a marine or alien. The predator's wristblade needs to be charged to be worth anything, and in multiplayer, you have to be very good to pull off hitting enemies with the wristblade because it actually has a delay.
2. Very minor, but eh, get off the elevator then?
3. Press the console key (default is tilde (~)). This will bring the message back up. Although if you didn't know this, I understand the frustration.
4. Speargun ammo is located in blue predator numerals in the bottom left. You start off with 30 spears and don't encounter any pickups. Each full cluster represents 9.
5. I don't know what you're on about. In Training mode, you get 9 saves; in Realistic you get 4, and in Director's Cut you get 2. For the original release of AVP 99, they didn't include saves at all. That was how badass it was. You needed to do the whole thing in one go.
6. The facehugger won't hit you if you keep moving. If you got facehugged, it's because you stopped moving to find it. It also takes a second before it leaps on your face. If it's that much of a problem, spam your pulse grenades, get out the tracking mode of the smartgun, or spam the flamethrower.