MichaelFurlong: Hmmm, I am not really into These massive open RPGs ( I tend to get bored). However I have been meaning to give one a try, what should I go for:
Oblivion
Two worlds
Rissen
Gothic
Any others worth mentioning?
Oblivion GoTY edition if you like fantasy and love the ability to do what you want
Fallout 3 has more structure and a future shooty feel, same with Boarderlands, even more structure and nearly liner at times.
Any of the Stalkers will give you an open world sort of structured feeling.
Risen will open up the choice system, fully open world, forced by player choice into a role. Its an extreme roleplaying game where choices honestly do matter to a point and no 2 games play the same.
Morrowind feels liner but its truly open, once you get used to the environment your set.
The Gothics, 1,2 are hard as nails.... roughest toughest games you'll ever play, but they are great concepts of what can be done with a truly set world whats not created around you but you must learn to live in it.
Gothic 3 needs, requires the fan patch, after that its a great game, in the vein of Two Worlds and Risen... Risen has the most polish, then Two Worlds and then Gothic 3...
Divinity II is alright.... but the awesome stuff doesn't happen till your nearly done and its more linear...
OK so for open ended no rules do what ever you have:
Oblivion
Fallout 3
Risen (sort of)
Two Worlds
Morrowind
And the Gothics
Coming up with structure is:
the 3 STALKERS
Borderlands
Console games like this concept are:
Prototype
Infamous
Conan
Vikings: Battle for Asgard
Grand Theft Auto 4
Folklore (sort of)
Just Cause 2
Saints Row 2
Thats all i can recommend looking into. Vikings: Battle for Asgard was amazingly fun. Short as games go unless you are an explorer and take your time... i loved it though, wonderful buy.