CymTyr: The first person to reply with the game I wishlisted back in 2008 upon joining the site will receive an Origin key for Mirror's Edge.

Hint 1: The game is not on GOG, but will be soon.
Hint 2: The game came out in 1988.
Final Hint: The game is squad-based.

BTW if you try to find it in the wishlist it won't be there. It was removed when a newer entry for the same game was made which received a hell of a lot more votes than the original listing (mine), and mine was flagged as a duplicate.

EDIT: As an added bonus, I will give you a Populous Origin key. I already have it on GOG.

Garrett24601: :Looks at avatar:

misteryo: Small Soldiers?

CymTyr: I'm surprised no one's gotten it yet, Garrett. I'm assuming you know, so spill the beans and claim your codes ;)
CymTyr: Negative, ghostrider. Look closely at my post. Now look to the left of my post. The answer should become obvious.

CymTyr:

Superbal: Fallout?

CymTyr: What came before Fallout?

CymTyr: What came before Fallout?

Garrett24601: I was trying to be subtle.
Already have the origin stuff. +1 to you.

Superbal: Wasteland?

CymTyr: Thanks and +1 right back at ya :)
CymTyr: DINGDINGDING :) Thanks - codes incoming via PM

Austrobogulator: Waaaasteland

CymTyr: Oh so close :)

ww_gog: It was typing in all the extra "a" that cost him precious seconds.

akhliber: Hey folks :)

Command & Conquer: Red Alert 3 - Uprising (Origin) anyone?

scpdepo: May i ?