Narakir: Stalingrad, come on Stalingrad not some city in Sibera, the most important city and battle of WW2 isn't in the right place where it should be, how could have the beta testers let such a thing happen ? Honestly, the current state of things urges you to try/stay with HOI2 which is cheaper and will be nearly bug-less with the next community patch, plus there are tons of good mods and community improvements for it.
They're claiming they placed Stalingrad where they did for balancing reasons (probably to make it a lot harder for the Germans to capture, like it was in WW2), but I feel that's just a load of horseshit.
I expect the maps to be accurate, and that does not mean placing Stalingrad halfway to Vladivostok. They've also gotten the location of several other historically insignifact cities like
New York wrong.
Apparently stuff like New York is going to get fixed in an upcoming patch, but Stalingrad stays where it is due to gameplay concerns. Can't they just scale up the difficulty of taking it otherwise? It sort of ruins the realism for me when such an important target is placed nowhere near it's correct location.
At least the map is a lot more modable in HoI3. If Paradox aren't fixing it, I'm sure there are plenty of fans who will.