jesskitten: snip.....
My starting vote for the day today is Ubivis. Why? I already outlined some points earlier, even though with Baz being town, that invalidates some (not all) of it.
- But you claimed a role (nurse) that was very doctorly sounding. Yes, that does not make you a doctor. But who here, if you were Mafia, would not have targetted him with a roleblock or a kill? The townie motivation for claiming something like that is to draw the night kill to you if you were a vanilla townie. But if that doesn't happen, then heaps of suspicion are on you because this is not one kill most Mafia pass on to make town suspicious of them or whatever - they always get killed or roleblocked. Always.
- You were not killed.
- You were not roleblocked.
Therefore, scum.
Vote Ubivis
That is an extremely good point Jess - it hangs on the fact that the Mafia would roleblock a power only hinted at (Ubivis never came out and said doc, but Nurse is sailing pretty close to the wind in anyones book!) instead of a known power role claimed by Typhoon - would the Mafia not play safe and block the known power role, as claimed? But then, if they did, surely they would go for the nightkill on Ubivis, just in case he was a power role himself!
Massive
FoS at Ubivis.
This IS all assuming Typhoon is telling the truth of course - he himself did manage to get to L -2 yesterday, so not exactly covered with glory.
Buuut, since the Claim, has done nothing further to raise suspicions. Still, not entirely trustworthy to me, so only a FoS at Ubivis instead of a vote, for now.
Also - there are far too many quiet people for my liking in this game - can we have some reasoned arguments and theories from others as well? It seems to be the same old few willing to put themselves up for ridicule and argument...longer you stay quiet, scummier you look to me....