Posted March 16, 2011
jesskitten: Ah, doh, Damuna didn't get to/want to play in Zchinque's game! Aww. :(
Are either of the setups open? Ie, do we or will we know off the bat what roles/quantities of each are in the game? Only reason I ask is that if Damuna did confer with Z to check the setup for GM2, then he'll have quite the massive advantage over everyone else in it going in, by knowing if there are (for example) 8 townies, 3 mafia, and one SK, and what power roles are in each.
Not saying the convo did happen though, but just wanted to cover the bases and make sure there was no possibility for any sort of misunderstanding later, and so the mafia don't have to NK Zchinque in Night 1 if they think he knows too much. :P
I have given some opinions on what I consider good design choices in general - such as don't have a mafia member with two votes, avoid serial killers in a 12-man game, and so on. I have no idea about any specifics of the setup. Are either of the setups open? Ie, do we or will we know off the bat what roles/quantities of each are in the game? Only reason I ask is that if Damuna did confer with Z to check the setup for GM2, then he'll have quite the massive advantage over everyone else in it going in, by knowing if there are (for example) 8 townies, 3 mafia, and one SK, and what power roles are in each.
Not saying the convo did happen though, but just wanted to cover the bases and make sure there was no possibility for any sort of misunderstanding later, and so the mafia don't have to NK Zchinque in Night 1 if they think he knows too much. :P
Edit: and I'm fairly certain both setups are closed.
Post edited March 16, 2011 by Zchinque