boct1584: And after receiving an angry PM from him, I belatedly realize that was a bit tactless. gameon, I apologize for saying you were an idiot. Perhaps the better way to put it would be that you didn't seem to be trying very hard.
You are not the first person to recieve it. :-/
boct1584: New question is: What does his alignment tell us about what he was saying, and about who voted for him? At the risk of repeating myself, cardflip was NEVER used when I played at Bemanistyle and DDR Freak.
And this is why it's not same as lynch. You ask what does it tell us about people voting him and it's valid question. If he was lynched you could question vote of much more people than after his stupid revelation.
N0x0ss: Now Vitek, care to explain something to me ?
I might not be the smarter person here, but please do tell me ....
I've did my research, and Nmillar and you have been playing several mafia games on this very forum, together.
Yet I don't see any kind of contact between you 2, It's as if you're
deliberatly trying to avoid talking to each-others directly, or keep these kind of inter-action as limited as possible,
We adressed each other. I even made post somehere about hm, IIRC. And isn't me talking about him with you contact too? I certainly had less contact with several other players (Violator, matti, planeshaper, boct, ayilen) and you don't mind it.
N0x0ss: Now please tell me, Why, instead of cornering Nmillar more to try and find out if he indeed is townie by putting pressure on him, you automatically takes his defense, but in a way that is very subtle ...
Hm I am defending him mostly because I thing you are barking at wrong tree and I think you are town so I would be more happy if you also tried to direct your enthusiasm elsewhere. You tunnelon him incredibly. You say gameon's town-flip does make players on his wagon susupicious but it is true only for nmillar, not for boct and Violator. So you are using something as a case against him but you are forgiving it to others.
N0x0ss: Why are there 2 experienced players whom have previously played against each-other, learned each-others techniques, making it look like they barely know each-others ? Am I the only one who finds it suspicious ?
Isn't he the 1st person you should logically suspect ?
Do you have additional insights we don't have ?
Maybe because we know what to expect from each other and thus nothing that the other has done forced us to scrutinize him more deeply?
People keep repeating how there is nothing to work with and now you are saying it looks bad we haven't attacked each other only because we have played together before.
Gazoinks gained 10 scum points for trying to not appear scummy. Mafia needs to concern themselves with this, town should care only for catching scum.
Planeshaper gained 4 scum points because he is trying to get rid of his responsibility.